Despite nearly 70 years of studying the score of Holst’s The Planets, I had never heard a live performance until Saturday in Jordan Hall. This “free educational concert” by students of the New England Conservatory’s Summer Orchestra Institute, augmented by select members of the Boston Festival Orchestra, was very ably conducted by BFO’s Artistic Director Alyssa Wang (whom I wrote about HERE in July 2022); her technique has much matured from when I first saw her two years ago, having become at once more flexible and precise with little excess motion. Holst’s score calls for a big ensemble, woodwinds by three and fours with several extra players: a second piccolo, an alto flute, a bass oboe, six horns, a tenor tuba, an organ (absent the silent Jordan Hall Skinner an electronic keyboard served), extra percussion, and a women’s chorus (offstage in the final movement). The only lack that I could see was the second harp, and many parts were noticeably doubled by even more players. This size can mean enormous volume, but also varied richness of timbre, which Holst, more skillfully than all but a few masters of his own time, could fully exploit. And the enthusiastic stage-filling contingent of already mature-sounding students and ringers made the most of the score.

“Mars” was emotionally shattering, especially when one remembered that Holst, not knowing what lay ahead, completed the score of this “Bringer of War” movement in June 1914, just a month before the cataclysm of the Great War exploded over Europe. Those col legno notes by the full string section really do work. “Venus, the Bringer of Peace” began with a bobbled F on solo horn, which I mention not only because it is one of the best-known difficult entrances in the horn literature, but because the youthful hornist carried off the rest of the movement with lovely tone and superb control. The ingeniously bitonal “Mercury” followed with fleet muted strings. When “Jupiter” finished, we heard a brief scattering of applause; who can forget that famous hymn from the middle section? At the end of “Saturn” the overlapping four flutes called for in the score were increased to seven, including two alto flutes if my vision was correct. “Uranus” arrived as an elegantly noisy magician, with the four-note timpani motif doubled. “Neptune, the Mystic” suitably cast its mystery, but it should have achieved an even quieter pianissimo, what with probably the most elaborate celesta part in the repertory since the Sugar Plum Fairy. The offstage women’s chorus projected insufficiently pure tone through the open stage door, and its contralto line couldn’t be heard at all — small weaknesses in a thoroughly gratifying effort.
Wang explained that recently deceased Kaija Saariaho had named the concert’s leadoff number, Asteroid 4179: Toutatis, for an actual astronomical object, a two-kilometer rock fragment between Mars and Jupiter, and therefore a sister orbital to Holst’s better-known masterpiece. Saariaho’s five minutes sounded like so many other recent orchestral commissions by dealing in multiply divisi strings, massive clusters of tutti tones from pp to ff, occasional twinkles of high-register color, everyone playing all the time with either ostinato patterns or drowsily sostenuto notes, and disclosing no perceptible progression or development.
I am perforce reconstructing some information for this review from a variety of exterior sources because NEC/BFO printed no handouts for this concert. The proffered QR code brought forth the essential information about the players, but within moments of my entering Jordan Hall an announcement ordered me to turn my phone off. Does this pointless parsimony actually save trees?
BFO closes its Jordan Hall summer season on July 28th with Scheherazade and Qigang Chen’s Franco-Chinese masterpiece Er Huang.
