IN: Reviews

Symphony’s Mighty Organ Surfaces

by

Michael Gandolfi (file photo)

In his second year as assistant conductor of the Boston Symphony Orchestra, young French conductor Samy Rachid brought his forebears, Berlioz, and Saint-Saëns to full Symphony Hall life, and Paris’s Notre Dame Cathedral organist Olivier Latry invoked the might of the Æolian-Skinner-Foley-Baker. Michael Gandolfi’s 2015 BSO commission for organ and orchestra commemorating the Armenian Holocaust also resurfaced.

Thursday evening’s concert was my first encounter with the new assistant conductor as well as his “subscription debut.” Even with his complete body involved, Rachid’s recherché presence on the podium suggested innocence. A long, outstretched arm with the baton pointed straight forward and a sweeping right-to-left move echoed fencing, both arms in restricted mirroring, a butterfly. Obvious joy spread particularly throughout the French portions of the program.  

Berlioz’s romanticized drama unfolded with the BSO modestly dreaming of a heroic adventure that gave way to indistinct feelings of apprehension. Expectations of Gallic glory from the brasses, cheers from the woodwinds, and excitement from the strings—the kind the composer imagined—were lowered; the cause being neither the tuba standing in for the anachronistic ophicleide Berlioz originally scored nor the toll father-time has taken on Waverly Overture’s unconventionality. Rachid’s and BSO’s up-tempo only revived certain of its fantasticness.

Before intermission came Ascending Light written in memory of organist Berj Zamkochian, a longtime BSO collaborator, and to commemorate the centennial of the Armenian genocide. Initially, New England Conservatory’s Michael Gandolfi, pondered “How am I going to incorporate Armenian culture into this piece and pay respect to those who lost their lives in the Armenian Holocaust?” His answer in part was to suffuse the work with quotations from the traditional “Lullaby of Tigranakert” and the Armenian hymn tune “Aravot lousaber” (trans. Ascending Light). Patched together were chorale settings, one for organ and another for brass, variations on the cradle song named after the capital, protracted textures, some conspicuously repetitious, and a heavily pounding beat.

With everyone in lockstep, the Symphony No. 3, Organ by Camille Saint-Saëns, often described as questioning, grand, and triumphant was thrillingly reborn. An early long-breathed fading memory from the oboe prophesied a new kinship formed of newcomer Samy Rachid and the proven Boston Symphony Orchestra. Lickety-split passages of a Schubertian kind first from the strings then from the winds drew attention to intense precision. With the organ console sitting nearly offstage, prayerfulness crept in by way of Latry’s cathedral practice, as low humming pedal tones soothed. In the ensuing Allegro moderato Rachid demanded forceful beats by clenching a fist that he drove into an open hand. How long have symphony-goers gazed at the golden pipes adorning the Hall? As Latry registered mightily in the Maestoso, the wait was over.

“I have given it all that I had to give.” Words of composer Saint-Saëns had to have inspired this revival before a mass of exhilarated listeners. It was with this life-giving Symphony No. 3, Organ closing the concert from Rashid, Latry, and the Boston Symphony that we remembered organist Berj Zamkochian heard on the touted Munch 1959 RCA Victor recording of the very same work.

Organist Olivier Latry and BSO Assistant Conductor Samy Rachid (Hilary Scott photo)

Since Latry played no encore prompts a few words here about the organist for those unfamiliar with his art. Heard on recordings, the well-worn Bach Toccata and Fugue in D Minor from Olivier Latry throws the fear of God into anyone in earshot of the organist, hands and feet effortlessly activating multiple keyboards and sizable panels of tonal color. His opening of the Toccata is by far the scariest yet—beware Dracula! Latry’s own on-the-spot, improvised creations have evinced similar fierceness. 

David Patterson, Professor of Music and former Chair of the Performing Arts Department at UMass Boston, was recipient of a Fulbright Scholar Award and the Chancellor’s Distinction in Teaching Award. He studied with Nadia Boulanger and Olivier Messiaen in Paris and holds a PhD from Harvard University. He is the author of 20 Little Piano Pieces.

7 Comments »

7 Comments [leave a civil comment (others will be removed) and please disclose relevant affiliations]

  1. Re Mogulmeister comments on Bruckner (yes, of course, a bit off-topic!), Nelsons did a moderate amount of Bruckner in his earlier years here – including not only the 4th, 7th, and 9th but also the rarely played 3rd and especially the 6th (this last a remarkable performance). He has been labeled as a “major” Bruckner conductor, but sadly, we’ve seen none of it in past 5 years.

    Comment by Jim Perrin — October 29, 2024 at 2:02 pm

  2. The live performances of the Saint Saens 3rd symphony in the late fifties featured E Power Biggs. I recall as a Medical student attending the Friday afternoon concert and hearing the SS 3rd with Biggs and Munch. It was so exciting that I returned on Sat. night to hear it again. As exciting as that commercial with B Zamkochian recording is, the live performances by Munch – especially of the French music was even more emotional – I have never heard such playing again over all these years. If you can find some of the tapes made by WGBH of those concerts one can get an idea of Munch and his French music . The BSO archives likely has these performances on tape swell.

    One other anecdote. In the 1950’s there was a Rexall drug store directly across Huntingden Ave from Symphony Hall. When I arrived for my Sat eve performance I stopped at the drug store and who was sitting alone at the counter? E Power Biggs. So I sat down and introduced myself and we had a very pleasant conversation. In those days Biggs was under contract to CBS for recordings and the BSO was recording only for RCA Victor. That is why Zamkochian did the recordings.

    Herbert Rakatansky MD
    Clinical Professor of medicine Emeritus
    Brown University

    Comment by Herbert Rakatansky — October 16, 2024 at 11:36 pm

  3. I completely agree with you, Jonathan. It was a superb concert. And it makes me really want to hear more of Samy Rachid. With the caveat that you never want to project off of just one concert, I suspect Rachid’s going to have a bright future. I can’t think of another assistant BSO conductor’s concert in recent memory that was any better than this one – or even came close to it.

    Comment by Mogulmeister — October 13, 2024 at 7:38 am

  4. We have just returned from a magical night of music. All selections were gloriously performed, beginning with a sprightly interpretation of the Berlioz overture, followed by a breathtaking dialog between the orchestra and organ, the latter played superbly by Msr. Latry in Mr. Gandolfi’s marvelous commission. We were greatly moved by Mr. Gandolfi’s composition, and had the pleasure of speaking with him later- it’s wonderful to hear a contemporary piece that is not ashamed to fully embrace tonality!

    It seemed one could not do better than these two compositions, but for me, this amazing young conductor hit the musical equivalent of a “grand slam” home run in his interpretation of the Saint Saens Organ Symphony. I have heard numerous live and recorded performances over the years, but in my opinion, Mr. Rashid had a flawless understanding of the optimal tempi and dynamic contrasts that literally supercharged this piece. Clearly, his vision was enthusiastically accepted by our amazing musicians. And of course, Msr. Latry allowed Mike Foley’s restored masterpiece to purr and roar at the right places, leading to the sensational climax this piece can create under expert hands- indeed, all concerned deserve copious praise. It’s a night like this one in our fantastic Symphony Hall which reinforces my belief, now in the twilight of my life, that nothing replaces a great live performance.

    Comment by Jonathan Kleefield — October 12, 2024 at 11:00 pm

  5. Mogulmeister Performances of Bruckner symphonies in Boston are rare. However, the 8th was performed in Symphony Hall on October 15, 2021 by the Boston Philharmonic under the direction of Benjamin Zander.

    Comment by Bennett — October 12, 2024 at 4:20 pm

  6. My apologies…I mispelled the organist’s last name – it should have been Olivier Latry.

    One other unrelated comment – it’s really a great disappointment to this listener that the BSO could not find room on the schedule for the performance of a Bruckner symphony at any point in 2024, the 200th anniversary of the birth of Anton Bruckner. When one considers how other top orchestras treated this anniversary (from the Concertgebouw performing all 9 symphonies in one season, to the Berlin Philharmonic touring the world with Bruckner’s 5th, etc.), the BSO stands out by having completely ignored it. That’s a disservice to all of us in my opinion.

    Additionally, it would be nice for the BSO to program other Bruckner symphonies than #7, 4, and 9 – which seem to be the Bruckner symphonies we typically get to hear (if we get to hear them at all). Bruckner’s 8th symphony and Bruckner’s 5th symphony are LONG overdue to be heard in Boston. And while I love Andris Nelsons overall and feel we are very fortunate to have him here in Boston, his Bruckner in performance and recording has generally not convinced me as being among his musical strengths–and thus it would be nice to hear some other conductors performing Bruckner in Boston.

    Comment by Mogulmeister — October 12, 2024 at 2:02 pm

  7. It’s wonderful that the BSO has brought back Michael Gandolfi’s “Ascending Light.” When it premiered in 2015, it brought down the house with a thunderous, outsized audience response the likes of which I’ve never heard before in Symphony Hall for any new work. “Ascending Light” is tremendous and deeply moving, and it’s an accessible tonal work that still manages to reveal and unfold over its 25 minutes in a manner that indicates substance. I loved it when we heard it in 2015 and I loved it even more hearing it a second time in 2024. It sounded like there was some sort of organ glitch on Thursday night, but regardless, Olivier Landry did a wonderful job as did the orchestra and Samy Rachid. Michael Gandolfi made a few comments before the performance that were insightful. It sounds like “Ascending Light” is getting picked up and performed elsewhere as well (Gandolfi reference a previous performance somewhere earlier in 2024), and it fully deserves to be heard. Kudos to the BSO for bringing back a second time. Let’s hope we continue to hear it in Boston, and let’s hope a recording of it gets made by the BSO rather than another orchestra.

    There are two new compositions the BSO has premiered/performed in the last decade that have struck me as major works that deserve to enter the permanent repertory (and many more that don’t): Julia Wolfe’s “Her Story,” and Gandolfi’s “Ascending Light.” What they have in common are that both are tonal, both have a sense of urgency that comes across loud and clear (and which the audiences “get”), and both are from mature composers rather than younger ones. We’ve heard some new tonal compositions from younger composers in recent years that while well-received by the audience, didn’t strike me as works of substance; not so the case with “Her Story” and “Ascending Light.” Both are substantive, major works that I hope we will continue to regularly hear in Boston.

    Samy Rachid did a very nice job with the Saint-Saens 3rd Symphony. Conducting from memory (as was also with the Berlioz overture), he made sharper accents in the work and opted for sonic impact in his interpretation more than subtlety. I thought his approach worked successfully. Even if this was a more muscular reading of the symphony, it fit and was quite enjoyable. There were times where it would have been nice to hear the BSO a bit more hushed than they often were, but again, the reading had a consistency to it and a point of view which was convincing. Kudos to Samy Rachid for giving us an individual interpretation of this warhorse and “selling it” successfully and convincingly.

    What a great start to the concert season for this listener!

    Comment by Mogulmeister — October 12, 2024 at 1:46 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, this comment forum is now closed.