Misunderstood himself, Saul was incapable of understanding others. He understood no one.He was alone and never managed to go beyond his solitude…. More complex than David, more tormented and tortured, Saul lifts us to mountain heights and then drops us in the abyss. Few destinies ever followed as fast as rhythm, or had as many vicissitudes in as short succession…. Few men knew such glory, and few lost it for such absurd reasons. From Elie Wiesel “Five Biblical Portraits.”
King Saul’s unforgettable appearance in the Hebrew Bible intrigued Rembrandt, Byron, Rilke, D.H. Lawrence, André Gide, and famously, G.F. Handel, whose 1738 oratorio about him was a initially a huge hit. This weekend’s hugely enjoyable production of Saul represented a most welcome return of H+H to this oratorio which they last performed in 2016. The singers, choir, and orchestra made a strong case not only for this drama-packed tale and its music, but also for attending H+H concerts, which invariably give its audience, and this listener, such joy.
Saul’s dizzying synopsis in the program book feels like it has the makings for a full season of soap opera. Among the five main characters (Saul, David, Merab and her sister Michal, and Jonathan), we witness a dizzying world of intrigue, power, jealousy, madness, treachery, romance, witchcraft, and murder.
Librettist Charles Jennens (1700-1773), of course, also provided the texts for Handel’s Messiah. Saul, Handel’s fourth oratorio, and an instant hit, comprises 86 numbers. Handel’s use of instruments, including a bewitching carillon that produces bell-like sounds, a triple harp (played to perfection by Maxine Eilander), a theorbo, bassoon, large kettledrums (which were borrowed from the Tower London for the premiere) and 3 trombones proved ever delightful.

This oratorio begins after the youthful David, on behalf of Israel, had killed the giant Goliath and vanquished the Philistines. From this moment of celebrations, David and Saul’s son Jonathan cement their friendships, and marriage proposals hang in the air. Saul’s daughter Merab, stunningly sung by soprano Sarah Brady, is offered to David, but this doesn’t work out, as she is a hopeless snob, and also, her sister Michal is crazy in love with David. (Be careful about falling for David, Michal. He is big trouble). The excellent soprano Amanda Forsythe fortuitously took the role of Michal after the cancellation of the original singer. Bass-baritone Neal Davies characterized Saul, and countertenor Christopher Lowry impersonated David. Tenor Linard Vrielink was Jonathan. All sang and inhabited the roles craftily.
Saul grows increasingly paranoid and jealous of David; efforts to allay his anger and frustration “with sounds divine” take the form of a heavenly delicate solo Symphony for harp. It apparently didn’t work. Saul orders his son Jonathan to kill David. Loving each other as they do, Jonathan cannot countenance the command. False promises are made between Jonathan and his father, who thinks up other ways for his son to kill David. The love story of Michal and David continues. Much gorgeous music ensues, until several hours later (three in all) we see Saul become increasingly unhinged.
Saul seeks supernatural help from the Witch of Endor (banned under Saul’s rule) and consults with the ghost of Samuel. Full of rage, David descends into gloom, hearing that Saul and his sons were killed in battle. We hear perhaps the most famous of pieces from Saul, “the Dead March.”
It is promised that David will be the new (improved) kind who will unify the county. The Dead March, written in the un-funereal C major, has featured in the obsequies for George Washington, Abraham Lincoln, and Winston Churchill.
We recognize five well-acted (and sung) walk-ons from the chorus: Jonas Budris, David McFerrin, Steven Soph, Stephan Reed (the plum told of the Witch of Endor) and Ryne Cherry. Lovely voices, all, they contributed significantly to the production. The superb H+H chorus acted in important moments as observers in the Greek drama tradition. Conductor and Music Director Jonathan Cohen allowed every minute to sparkle in this very satisfying production.

Yes, indeed. Thank you, Steven, for pointing that out.
Comment by Susan Miron — October 9, 2025 at 12:49 pm
Congrats, too, to H+H’s City Sing and Youth Choruses, performing alongside the H+H Chorus!
Comment by Steven — October 8, 2025 at 5:20 pm