IN: Reviews

Hindoyan, Wang, and BSO Scintillate

by

Domingo Hindoyan, conductor (Winslow Townson photo)

Thursday night’s Boston Symphony concert was a big program — by its own timing, 81 minutes of music, all modern and all scintillating, with Yuja Wang at the center of attention, and with Domingo Hindoyan, a re-visitor whom I had not heard before, conducting.

Three Dance Episodes from Leonard Bernstein’s On the Town, all short but spicy, led off with a burst of perfect mid-1940s color and rhythm. It was very refreshing to hear not only a youthful orchestral mastery that expertly merged orchestral with big-band jazz sound, but also to enjoy the bold inventiveness in harmony and rhythm. I had been impressed just last year by Bernstein’s Symphony No. 1 (“Jeremiah”) when BMOP performed it in Jordan Hall [my review HERE], a more serious and studied work composed at about the same time, and to hear these lighter-weight but still meaty Broadway delightfully demonstrated Bernstein’s irrepressible talent, complete with high-register E-flat clarinet, trumpets with cup mutes, bouncing trap set, and a waltz bass for “New York, New York, it’s a wonderful town.”

The audience cheered when Yuja Wang came on stage wearing a silver lamé dress fully open at the back, and totally fearless. Prokofiev’s Piano Concerto No. 2 in G Minor, a rarely heard four-movement work, which Russell Sherman once, in total awe, described as “massive”, never fazed her. That massiveness particularly applies to the first and longest movement, 4/4 and 12/8, Andantino, which piled up successive virtuosic episodes — it’s hard to describe them as developed, because everything unfolded in relentless four-bar phrases — but the cumulative effect surely reached an apogee, especially with a 68-bar cadenza, soaring up and tumbling down, thrice reaching fff before the orchestra re-entered full brass. Having this behemoth end on a hushed, low-register fadeout made for a perfect anticlimax. The Vivace scherzo that followed, a two-minute moto perpetuo melodic line, came as a distinct relief to the triumphant first movement, as did the Intermezzo, a pesante exercise with booming Tchaikovsky-like big chords. The finale, Allegro tempestoso, regularly reached the decibel level of the first movement, but provided a contrast in chorale-like passages, and emphasized a folk-style melody that reminded one of Musorgsky’s Songs and Dances of Death. One remembers that this huge piece is situated historically in the middle of the Great War, following Rachmaninov’s path into international fame and exile, and came five years after the composer’s brilliant but shorter and more easygoing First Concerto (D-flat major); a few years later, the much more economical and precise Third Concerto (C major), made its remarkable impression. This Prokofiev, as Diaghilev remarked to Stravinsky, is “full of splinters.”

Yuja Wang, piano (Winslow Townson photo)

It was fascinating to see Yuja Wang toss off the wildly leaping concerto with total energy and accuracy, not without effort but without danger. I found myself wishing in vain that she had played some wrong notes; then I would have believed. The audience twice leaped to its feet for a cheer lasting several minutes after this heroic performance. She gave us an encore, too: Schubert’s Gretchen am Spinnrade, Op. 2, in Liszt’s arrangement.

After the intermission we heard Aaron Copland’s Third Symphony, a well-respected but seldom-heard work (1946) that we should now consider a heady classic; despite weaknesses, and there are some, it’s certainly a Great American Symphony, an emblematic product of neoclassicism and World War II. The last time I heard it here was six years ago [HERE], and I remember commenting on the difficulty of the ensemble rhythms and the precarious passage work for strings. The same kinds of difficulties became apparent last night, and certain places didn’t come together precisely. Possibly one more rehearsal, such as Koussevitzky would have demanded when he conducted the premiere, would have smoothed these out. This would have been a better symphony if Copland had omitted the snare drum, slapstick, ratchet, and anvil. Nevertheless, we heard much that radiated Copland’s orchestral sensitivity at its most beautiful — the chorale-like wind sound in the first and third movements, the crystalline counterpoint in the jazzy fugato finale, and, of course, the famous Fanfare “For the Common Man,” known to every college or high-school band student in its simplified original version. Domingo Hindoyan kept good control of all of these very expressively, and the orchestra answered. (Perhaps the orchestra found Domingo Hindoyan’s twirling beat patterns insufficiently precise some of the time. I couldn’t determine what he was doing with his too-much-mirroring left hand, but the players could tell, and they backed him up; it was interesting to see him tuck his stick under his left forearm in order to direct the Fanfare with his hands alone, very successfully.) The descent from the fff climax in the finale, with its delicate tracery of two piccolos, two flutes, two harps, and piano as the first-movement theme returns cyclically, was especially fine, as was the grandiose buildup to the final pages (as six years ago, the original ending was used, despite the version of pp. 152-153 in the printed score, supposedly demanded by Bernstein). Last night’s traversal celebrated its status as a great American symphony.

Mark DeVoto, musicologist and composer, is an expert on the music of Alban Berg, Debussy, and other early 20th-century composers. A graduate of Harvard College (1961) and Princeton (Ph.D., 1967), he has published on many music subjects, and edited the revised fourth (1978) and fifth (1987) editions of Harmony by his teacher Walter Piston.

19 Comments »

19 Comments [leave a civil comment (others will be removed) and please disclose relevant affiliations]

  1. For those who asked if the concert was recorded, link to WCRB for the Saturday night performance:

    https://www.classicalwcrb.org/show/the-boston-symphony-orchestra/2025-09-10/yuja-wang-prokofiev-and-the-boston-symphony

    Comment by Geo. — November 2, 2025 at 11:54 pm

  2. Mr. Farber:

    Hear hear! Well said.

    Comment by John W. Ehrlich — November 2, 2025 at 6:57 pm

  3. Kudos to the conductor for choosing pieces that have something to do with one another, that “speak” to one another. In other words: a real PROGRAM, rather than a group of pieces of about the right length.

    Comment by Daniel Farber — November 1, 2025 at 3:30 pm

  4. To clarify my statement about the rarity of concerto’s performance what I meant is that
    I have not heard it performed at BSO and that it is not in the repertoire of the current
    crop of major pianists. I did not mean to indicate that it has never been performed at the BSO
    .So Mr Hungerford is right in that sense. I also have the LP of John Browning’s performance.
    In my humble opinion I doubt that the concerto will overtake the popularity of the 3rd concerto.

    Comment by MIROSLAV VINTONIV — October 31, 2025 at 2:52 pm

  5. Mark, tom and I were at this concert Thursday night too! as non-professionals, was glad to read your comments which we share. Paula

    Comment by Paula Herman — October 29, 2025 at 12:45 pm

  6. I’m a little surprised at comments about the rarity of Prokofiev’s Second Concerto. Perhaps I’m showing my age (49 years as a BSO subscriber), but I’ve heard the piece played by Horacio Gutiérrez, Viktoria Postnikova, Nicolas Hodges, and Yuj Wang herself (about ten years ago). A number of other pianists have played it in Boston, and I even heard a young pianist perform the concerto with the Quincy Symphony several years ago.

    In addition, I have two vinyl lp’s with the BSO (pianists John Browning and Nicole Henriot-Schweitzer). I do agree that it is a stunning concerto, and I think it may be overtaking the composer’s Third Concerto in popularity.

    Comment by George Hungerford — October 28, 2025 at 6:06 pm

  7. Shostakovich did an arrangement of Tea for Two. Perhaps a nod in that direction?

    Comment by Concordia — October 28, 2025 at 5:22 am

  8. A rather extreme interpretation of Tea For Two was Art Tatum’s signature, and his arrangement of it is a popular encore among certain pianists who revere Tatum’s radical virtuosity-as-artistry, in particular Yuja Wang.

    Comment by SamW — October 27, 2025 at 2:21 pm

  9. The piece I was looking for was the toccatina by Kapustin–thank you! First hit on Google and iTunes were both Yuja Wang performances.

    Comment by Sam — October 26, 2025 at 7:50 pm

  10. I was at the Friday performance. Ms. Wang was all that and a bag of chips. That concerto is TORRENTIAL and as noted above she is both fearless and flawless.

    I didn’t know the Copland but was unconvinced by Mr. Hindoyan’s leadership. Not only was he doing an awful lot of drum major hand doubling but he never rose to anything like the triumphant affirmation that Copland winds up so well. It all felt dutiful from the podium, to me at least.

    BUT – the brass section was superlative in and around the Fanfare! Even burnished tone and precise ensemble top to bottom. The winds and strings weren’t too bad either! Are we living a Golden Age….?

    Comment by Mark Dirksen — October 26, 2025 at 6:23 pm

  11. ATTENDED FRIDAY’S CONCERT
    -NEEDLESS TO SAY YUJA WANG NEVER DISSAPOINTS WITH HER BRILLIANT
    EXECUTION OF THE MOST DIFFICULT PIANO CONCERTOS-IN MORE THAN 40
    YEARS OF ATTENDING BSO CONCERTS I NEVER HEARD THIS DEMANDING WORK
    I ONLY WISH I COULD HAVE HEARD HOROWITZ, RUBINSTAIN OR VAN CLIBURN
    PLAY THE CONCERTO-IT WAS NOT IN THEIR REPERTOIRE.
    THANK YOU YUJA FOR “MAKING MY DAY.” UNFORGETTABLE EXPERIANCE!!
    ON TOP OF THE CONCERTO SHE ADDED 2 ENCORES -HER OWN RENDITION OF TEA FOR TWO AND KAPUSTIN’S TOCCATINA

    Comment by MIROSLAV VINTONIV — October 26, 2025 at 4:50 pm

  12. A jazzy performance of “Tea for Two” was the first encore on Friday afternoon, and perhaps evening. I wondered about the reason for what seemed to me a surprising choice. Perhaps it’s that “Tea for Two” was written the same year the revised version of the concerto premiered?

    Comment by Annie — October 26, 2025 at 4:42 pm

  13. I believe encores on Saturday were the Mendelssohn Songs without Words Op.67 No.2 and Nikolai Kapustin’s Toccatina from 8 Concert Etudes Op.40

    Comment by Terry F — October 26, 2025 at 2:31 pm

  14. What was the first encore Saturday night?

    I didn’t hear the Tea for Two tune in the second encore.Is that really what it was?

    Yuja was AMAZING!

    Comment by Cecilia — October 26, 2025 at 11:31 am

  15. Sam – The other encore was “Tea for Two”.

    Comment by Doug — October 26, 2025 at 9:18 am

  16. WGBH/WCRB typically broadcast (and record and stream) the Saturday performances. Sadly, the Friday concerts have gone the way of the rest of civilized music radio in Boston.

    Comment by Concordia — October 26, 2025 at 7:05 am

  17. Amazed by the Prokofiev–don’t think I’d heard it before. Would have been incredible even in less capable hands, but Yuja Wang is always a treat.

    Does anyone know the piece that she played for her second encore on Saturday night? Reminded me of something from Gulda’s “Play Piano Play”, but I’m pretty sure it’s not that.

    Comment by Sam — October 26, 2025 at 12:40 am

  18. Was the concert recorded???

    Comment by Richard Milstein — October 25, 2025 at 4:11 pm

  19. Yuja Wang Prokofiev’s piano concerto No 2 was Spellbinding and The Copland’s Symphony No 3 was Perfecton

    Comment by Marcia L Jackson — October 25, 2025 at 3:21 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, this comment forum is now closed.