Last night’s BSO subscription concert progressed from a swim to a recently discovered floating ostinato island, through a rewarding if predictable rendition of an inevitable FM favorite, to a multi-flowering hothouse of motion and passion.
The young Gabriella Smith observes nature and worries about its decline through activism and music. She uses “the natural world as a metaphor for musical structure and process, or vice versa.” Her ostinato-laden Bioluminescence Chaconne began somewhat in the manner of Petruschka, but where Stravinsky piled on episodes with mounting rhythmic furor, Smith’s work flowed and churned like a chilly Humbolt current in whose depths monsters lurk. And is the chaconning tympani the lurking monster? The onomatopoetic 17-minute arc encompassed a long crescendo before ending pianissimo, never having quite radiated luminosity as much as currents and foam. The score directs string players to employ “messy, noisy, unmeasured tremolos..stagger bow changes..occasionally allow finger drift to get to the next partial, percussion to sparse improvisatory hits… every four-ish bars and to occasionally throw in a dead stroke and to repeat push and pull rhythm out of synch with others. The instrumentarium includes tin cans, mixing bowls or other kitchen objects.” A BMInt colleague summarized her methods after reading the full score:
[It includes] abundant high-register woodwind patterns, four against five, etc.; string harmonics, lot of avant-garde playing techniques like so many other new orchestral scores, lots of senza misura, brass four against five over duplet bass line, abundant triads, especially in lower register, plenty of C major, and too much sostenuto. The music doesn’t move as much as it drifts, like accumulating snow.
BSO Assistant Conductor Anna Handler kept the progress steady, but it must have been difficult to keep time when bar lines became elusive at so many times, thus her cues must have been more helpful than her beat. She discerned and surfed the larger waves underneath the ripples.
Before their stint headlining Mozart’s very familiar Symphonia Concertante, BSO Concertmaster Nathan Cole and First Viola Steven Ansell told WCRB’s Brian McCreath, “There are not so many notes, the harmonies are mostly kind of standard. But funny enough, Mozart is such great music that you really have to work on it. And there are a lot of things in the violin part, in the viola part—we have freedom, but we’re playing the same music. So we probably have to talk a lot about articulations and where we’re going to put slurs and just character in general and how we’d like it to go.”

In a way, the standup pair also continued to lead and reinforce their respective sections by playing in the tuttis, but when they emerged as duoists, their very different personalities did in fact complement each other. If, in the deep middle movement, Cole’s aristocratic tone and manner of delivery evoked Donna Anna’s elegant but poignant “Non mi dir…”, then Ansell’s embodied the earthiness and humor of Leporello. Everything looks easier for the violin; thus we marveled at the effort of longer bow strokes and deeper digging in to make the more primitive viola project (scordatura tuning also helped). The polish of the encounters between the two esteemed colleagues and Handler’s success in setting the stage for their moments gratified us. Balance between orchestra and soloists worked and the two soloists seemed to revel getting into one others’ sounds, especially when they were in octaves. Handler, of course, took some of her cues from the soloists, crouching when they sighed, extending the long lines, rather than clipping short phrases. We’ve certainly heard versions with more fire, with deeper yearning, and/or more early-music-crispness, but this satisfying albeit un-surprising, large scale (lots of strings) outing did not disappoint. Consistently magnificent work from the paired horns of Michael Winter and Austin Ruff gave us goose bumps.
From Tchaikovsky’s Swan Lake, Handler culled a suite of ten mostly familiar dances or scenes from the composer’s 29 plus introduction; it came in at 45 minutes rather than the nearly three hours that a full production can run. With balletic flair, she inspired a tremendously outgoing spirit from the band as the composer’s masterful variety of forms and brilliant orchestration kept us riveted. Would that Boston had an opera house where a large orchestra of the BSO’s level could accompany an accomplished corps of dancers replete with scenery, costumes and lighting. Handler didn’t need all those the fluttering hands and en-pointe cavortings, that occupy a ballet stage; on Thursday night she and the players dished up a scrumptious a musical feast of virtual choreography that moved with style and savor. Naturally some moments stood out. The introduction, foreshadowing the intense seductions (this Swan may also have been a friend of Leda) as well as the tumult of grand passions glowed in virtual footlights. Handler and the band nailed all the accents and quick tempo changes. The Dance of the Swans could not have moved us more. Jessica Zhou’s arpeggios, glissandos and chords poured forth with liquid authority and emotional truth. The violas introduced the swan with sadness and consolation before the concertmaster masterfully embellished it; then Blaise Déjardin’s emoting cello sealed the deal in a noble turn and duet with the concertmaster.
Other irresistible moments included Tom Rolfs’s blazing cornet solo and idiomatic accelerations in the Neopolitan dance, the castanets in the bouncy Spanish Dance, and a very ethnically secure whirling Hungarian Dance. The swinging Mazurka included a very fine duet of William Hudgin’s vocal clarinet and John Ferillo’s tactile oboe. The tone painting at the lakeside in number 28 summoned up a dangerous storm that cleared with the all’s-well signal. A spellbinding-breaking oboe solo began No. 29, a reprise and enlargement of the swan theme. What a blast, as the tremulating strings, rolling drums, and deep brass built up to a conflagration before Zhou’s celestial harp strains reminded us of the unfolding tragedy. The virtual velvet grand drape came down on a very satisfying night for all concerned.
Lee Eiseman is the publisher of the Intelligencer

Violin sound vs viola sound.
what violin, what viola, what bow, what strings, what hall ???
and, perhaps most of all, what player(s)?
a global comparison is not a possibility.
In the case at hand, the players were not a match, I don’t know about the instruments, but I do know that others have played that violin with very different results.
Comment by cecilia — February 11, 2026 at 8:07 pm
Is DM really saying that a violin is nothing more than high-pitched viola? All else equal??
Comment by denovo 2 — February 11, 2026 at 5:08 pm
Fancy ways of saying that generally (all else equal) their frequency responses are different, the violin having more and louder treble.
Comment by David Moran — February 11, 2026 at 3:56 pm
Surprising, isn’t it, that the viola, a much bigger instrument, would generally be rather less audible! The violin’s higher tuning and more compact shape actually allow it to cut through an orchestra, though, and project with greater volume and clarity. A viola’s larger dimensions cause the air inside to resonate more slowly, producing a more sumptuous tone but making the instrument quieter and a bit slower to respond; that and the longer, thicker strings require greater bow pressures and a quicker attack, if it is to keep up with the more nimble violin.
This may well be why Mozart instructed the viola soloist in the Eb Sinfonia Concertante to tune the strings up a half-step, scordatura, and wrote the part in D. Just that small adjustment might help the viola sound a little brighter and clearer. By the way, as usual, I found Steve Ansell’s mastery of these properties breathtaking.
Comment by nimitta — February 11, 2026 at 11:34 am
“It’s also worth noting that the viola being generally softer than a violin, Ansell’s invigorating attack kept the soloists on a more equal footing.”
What?
Comment by cecilia — February 9, 2026 at 7:24 pm
I attended Friday afternoon. I enjoyed the Gabriella Smith piece very much, although I found myself wondering part way into the piece whether I might enjoy it even more without the timpani. It never seemed integrated into everything else that was going on. Swan Lake was a lot of fun, even more enjoyable than I had anticipated. Mozart left me cold, but perhaps I’m missing the Mozart appreciation gene.
Comment by Barry — February 9, 2026 at 12:42 pm
I also attended the Saturday evening concert, cecilia, and I thought that Nathan Cole and Steve Ansell playing the Mozart together was an excellent idea.
As I hear it, the Sinfonia Concertante foregrounds two distinctive personalities in the violin and viola – is it far-fetched to imagine different genders? – engaged in a series of imaginative interactions. The richness of the contrasts between their personalities, conveyed by both timbre and style, seem to me no less intentional on the composer’s part than the robust admixture of their duets. Thus, the disparity in Cole and Ansell’s approaches rendered their exchanges vividly characterful, in keeping with Mozart’s operatic sensibilities.
It’s also worth noting that, the viola being generally softer than a violin, Ansell’s invigorating attack kept the soloists on a more even footing. And, by Saturday night’s performance, the soloists had achieved a wonderfully mellifluous refinement in their duo passagework. I very much enjoyed their performance, even if the orchestra, though adroitly conducted by the prodigious Anna Handler, was a bit too large to bring the score into sufficiently sharp focus at times. In this case, less might have been more.
Comment by nimitta — February 9, 2026 at 11:41 am
I attended the Saturday evening concert. Despite having a soft spot in my heart for living composers, I could find nothing interesting or enjoyable about the first piece on the program. And eight timpani, really?
Nathan Cole and Steven Ansell are definitely mismatched. Ansell’s robust, musical, sometimes even gutsy approach to his instrument is so far away from Cole’s thin, wiry sound and general approach that I wonder who thought their playing the Mozart together was a good idea.
Tom Rolfs is definitely the hero of the evening for me. Tchaikovsky was enjoyable. And Blaise – we are so fortunate to have him as principal cello!
Comment by cecilia — February 8, 2026 at 12:16 pm