

The left, the right, the back to nature movement, the joys of money and the virtues of poverty, democratic values versus monarchic rule…a woman with a little whip beating an imposter caveman into romantic submission, an impotent Maharaja with 27 wives…all provided fodder for the lyrical-satirical extravagance in last night’s Boston Modern Orchestra-Odyssey Opera production of The Last Savage. Who but Menotti would rhyme NATO with Spoleto? Characters included a wily but consoling Despina type as well as a hilariously menacing but essentially benign Alfio figure, a coloratura diva-dominatrix assoluta, a picture-perfect pasha, a broadly endowed Wall Street Maharina, and a chorus of archetypes. A total man of the theater and an unabashed eclectic, Menotti embraced, Rossini, Puccini (“Buongiorno” drew knowing laughs), G and S patter, even as he took a whiff of Prokofiev. His Royal Hunt march summoned up Berlioz. One never knew when the zaniness would melt into human warmth. His parlando, arias, and rigorously hysterical ensembles held our interest fully for two hours because the melodic invention, musical character development, and clever orchestration proved so winning. We humans are all the silly fools he showed us, but Menotti loves us nevertheless…even the dodecaphonists, the modern artists, and the fanciful theorists he parodies. But he’s clear that women of all sizes and shapes run the game of life.
An arranged marriage struck between Prince Kodanda the son of a Maharaja and Kitty a daughter of Scattergood, a Chicago millionaire, is repeatedly and ultimately thwarted by various machinations of topsy-turvydom. Abdul, a simple man is enamored of Sardula, the wily but consoling maid. He agrees to impersonate a wild man for $100,000 if he can ultimately marry Sardula. An anthropologist, Kitty takes him back home to Chicago to display for society (“Oh father, dear father, are you expecting me to go back again to Vassar without a single trophy?”) and falls in love with him. This is good, since Kitty and Kolanda can’t marry because they turn out to be siblings. Thus, Kodanda is betrothed to Sardula while Kitty and Abdul make love in a cave as the servants arrive with upscale accoutrements to make cave life more bearable for Kitty during gaps in her romance with Abdul. Scattergood (Kitty’s ’s father) resumes his affair with the Maharini which began on the Nile “when her hips were not so wide.” The Maharaja takes refuge in his stamp collection.
The 1963 opera, which I saw (as a high school student) in its US premiere at the Old Met in 1964, ran to 16 performances over two years, despite mixed to negative reviews in an era when Menotti was considered beneath the modernists’ contempt, in part because the Met showed such confidence in the work that it cast George London, Nicolai Gedda, Ezio Flagello, Roberta Peters, Teresa Stratas, and Lilli Chookasian. Beni Montresor’s elaborate sets looked gorgeous.

No money was wasted on scenery at the Huntington Theater. The orchestra of close to 50 occupied the back of the stage, leaving an apron of about 15 feet for the action. With only tables, chairs and a rolling hotel luggage rack as the savage’s restraints for props, Eve Summer blocked the action with delightful comic gestures, natural interactions, and non-stop but never relentless motion and business. Christopher Olsrtum’s mood-attentive lighting design somehow evoked jungles, palaces, and drawing rooms (with the help of scene-setting supertitles). Brooke Stanton’s scrumptious 1960s gowns owned the stage in the cocktail party. Kitty got four over the three acts plus a wonderfully ridiculous safari outfit. And we feasted on Stanton’s polychrome saris for the ladies of India.
In the title role, bass-baritone Phillip Lopez endowed Abdul with very resonant low notes and a gleaming top. His naïve and hapless character telegraphed mystification when not growling or beating his bare chest. Time stopped in his “Where will it end?” aria. Coloratura soprano Sharleen Joynt never mugged or camped Kitty as her stratospheric ornamentations glistened like polished pin pricks. Her mastery of the whip and her brief journey astride Abdul played to certain universal fantasies. She was funny without ever trying to be. Anya Matanovič, a sweet-voiced soprano, consoled in her aria “How shall my lips deny it,” yet she could also mug with the best. A comic genius, mezzo-soprano Michelle Trainor, deployed her lovely instrument and amply padded figure at key moments in the enterprise as the Maharini, “while she stuffs herself with honey, she makes money on the stock exchange.” Her hilarious seduction scene with Scattergood, the mellifluous baritone and master of the doubletake Gabriel Preisser, brought down the house. Cutting a princely figure, Omar Namji gave dulcet voice to Prince Kodanta, rising to penetrating high notes of passion in his great aria “Only for you, lovely Sardula.” The Maharaja, in the person of baritone Matthew Burns, ranged, in splendid tones from imagining himself to be running things, to acceptance of his subordination. The well-costumed 20-voice chorus made a fine, clear, and articulate sound, getting all the difficult rhythms, entrances and cutoffs perfectly. Fourteen of them gave worthy accounts of brief character roles.
Menotti wrote his original French libretto, but we heard George Mead’s English translation which included, romantic sentiments for some gorgeous arias, many witty couplets, a catalog aria comparing the millionaire Scattergood’s six skyscrapers to the Maharaja’s 99 little villages and six big towns, a brilliant septet, “Just a moment, just a moment, we do not intend to harm you, or deprive you of your freedom.” Consider “[The Maharini is] a sphinx of pure fat with neither nails nor bones… ,” “A woman’s sex appeal is man’s Achilles heel,” “This is getting sillier and sillier, but… his face looks so familiar, “Yes, we’ll show them our authority and tell them what to do,” “This is sinful, this is awful, because incest is not lawful.”
Every word came across in the dry, speech-friendly theater, where the proscenium arch admonishes all who tread its boards “To hold, as ‘twere, the mirror up to nature.” But comedy was clearly part of nature for Shakespeare. And the artful comedians on stage once again obeyed the dictum to reveal human truths.
Gil Rose considerately presided over a company of singers with comic and vocal genius and players who can make any composer sound great. They have shown doubters that Menotti is now an unabashed rather than a guilty pleasure. We make no apologies for having enjoyed this light, coy, self-referential, but knowing entertainment. It was astonishing how much came back to me from the Met performance of 63 years earlier. If we had heard it in Italian, we would have accepted it as the last true opera buffa.
Lee Eiseman is the publisher of the Intelligencer
More Winslow Townson Pictures below plus
Beni Montresor drawings from the 1964 Met production at the bottom


Good to read this review and about this performance. I saw ‘The Last Savage’ at Santa Fe Opera in 2011, which was a very entertaining and enjoyable production, especially given the dearth of comic operas from the latter part of the 20th century. It also became clear on several levels why the opera hasn’t retained much traction since 1964. Many situations and character portrayals are very cringe-inducing now, especially the depictions of the South Asian / Indian characters. (OK, the Americans are kind of caricatured too.) More importantly, the music isn’t good. It’s safe, tonal, tuneless wallpaper, IMVHO, and this was more probably the real reason for “the modernist’s contempt”. It’s a reasonably good time in the theater, though.
Comment by Geo. — April 15, 2026 at 2:26 pm
Management tells us that a sound recording from the weekend is in the can with a release date to be determined.
Comment by Lee Eiseman — March 16, 2026 at 9:56 am
Please tell us this was recorded, if not also filmed, for release on BMOP Sound!
Comment by Mark Dirksen — March 15, 2026 at 4:22 pm