The tempest about the decision not to renew Andris Nelsons’s appointment as conductor of the Boston Symphony Orchestra has become a full-blown hurricane. Its musicians and staff, as well as subscribers and attendees, have been publicly expressing dismay not only at the decision, but also at the way it was announced. (See Andris Nelsons to Depart BSO, which has received a record 23,900 views and 177 comments to date).
The letter from the BSO board emailed to its supporters on March 20th, “An update from the BSO,” did little to address the concert-going community’s concerns. First, it mentioned that “Over the past several weeks, many have understandably asked questions about the BSO’s direction….” We ask, who were among those “many”? Or not among them? How unfortunate that, before committing itself to a decision that is causing so much dissension, the “many” had not included its musicians and supporters. A well-constructed survey of both groups would not only have been in order, but if heeded, would have lent credence to the approach the board eventually took.
Second, the letter continued, “We owe you more clarity about that, and we want to offer it here. The BSO, like cultural institutions across this country, faces challenges. Attendance at our orchestra concerts has declined drastically over the past twenty years. Operating costs have risen sharply while traditional revenue sources have struggled to keep pace. The BSO has consistently operated with structural deficits and has drawn down more than $100 million from its reserves, over and above the regular annual endowment draw, to cover operating needs. Years of deferred maintenance have forced beloved spaces — including venues at Tanglewood — to close temporarily, and our marquee facilities require tens of millions of dollars in upgrades.”
The problems the BSO missive spelled out are endemic to our entire country in these times. The after-effects of Covid, with drop of attendance, and availability of on-line methods of listening to concerts, obviously also has played a part, seemingly not given enough credit for its negative effect by many cultural institutions. One does wonder how these problems have been addressed in the past few years by the BSO staff explicitly involved? The Development Department has 38 employees. The Marketing Department has 42. (The Press Office, by contrast, is down to three employees. Its inclusion within the Marketing Department does beg a few questions about autonomy and decision-making. One wonders if the PO helped with the communiques.)
Although not articulated, the Board seems to think that the problem is the repertoire (what else is there?). The goal of increasing attendance should not come at the cost of dumbing-down or popularizing the repertoire. Sadly, whatever the Board deems it to be, it misses the cause of the problem and therefore has offered the BSO community a supposed solution that is not only off-base but could prove catastrophic. And it is short-term. One can sympathize with its concerns, but for solutions, it is barking up the wrong tree. Yes, the audience for concerts has dropped significantly. But the reasons are not those assumed by BSO leadership.
Now to solutions:
The fault lies with three areas of American life that have been failing us of late: – education, involvement, and exposure. Schools and media. To be fair, these are, as noted, problems of modern society in America. The lowering of standards in public education has been covered in many areas, such as lack of reading or writing skills, mathematics, and education in the arts. I leave it to others to assess the damage to the history of art (my field, in practice), and here tackle music.

Education
Music education should be strengthened in our nation’s public schools. Many years ago, my husband and I had the good fortune to meet a fellow viewer at the Uffizi. Our conversation turned to, music. Our new friend, the late Michael Kamin, was a Hollywood composer of music for films. He founded a non-profit group, Mr. Holland’s Opus, to distribute instruments to students in public schools. According to Wikipedia, “Headquartered in Burbank, California, Mr. Holland’s Opus Foundation works to ensure that economically disadvantaged youth have access to the benefits of music education, which in turn supports their academic success and creative expression. As of 2025, the foundation has donated over 41,000 instruments (valued at more than $37 million) to nearly 2,000 schools in 49 states, Washington, D.C., and Puerto Rico, benefiting over 500,000 students nationwide.” Boston has a similar program, Project Step, headquartered conveniently within the BSO building,… And last but not least, programs for school visits by NEC students should be broadened.
By the same token, when children from local schools are taking part in a concert, they should not be relegated to performing from the corridor by the Massachusetts Avenue entrance but should somehow be brought on stage. This would capture their wonder, which could translate to loving the act of performing,… and later, enjoying as musician or audience.
Publicity:
The Marketing and PR Departments should concentrate on getting more coverage of concerts, upcoming and reviews, in the local press, as it used to be.
It is not too late for a survey. After the usual questions, ask the recipients if they have suggestions for solutions, and if they will participate in implementing them.
This is how to help the BSO survive for the next 145, or however many, years. Music is a necessary part of my life, as it is for many. May it thrive through our esteemed Boston Symphony Orchestra.
In fine: If the BSO wishes to attract a larger audience or keep its current one, it might try some more friendly approaches. There are some problems with current operations of the BSO that can be fixed immediately.
First, the telephone system is a disaster. Options offered are all geared to eating and purchasing; no indication, if one were so foolish as to try, to contact the librarian, the archives, publications, … And the final insult: One cannot leave a message. You are signed off on with a perfunctory “GoodBYE!”
Second: The Box office telephone number has truncated hours. Increase open box-office hours, or at least give the option to leave a message.
Third: When patrons wish to attend the pre-concert lecture, they come in and sit wherever they wish—usually, closer to the front, to hear well. There is ample time when the talk is over to go to their assigned seats. But the new rule is that you must sit in your assigned seat. How about if you are in one of the balconies rear? Recall this poor decision.
Fourth: Do more about the cost of regular tickets
Fifth: Make peace with the players and they will advocate positively.
Sixth: Intermission is so short that those who wait in line to purchase a drink often have to guzzle it down or leave it unfinished. It leaves a bad taste in their mouths.

Can anyone tell me why CEO Chad Smith entered into a contract to sell online for the BSO with TicketSales.com of Dallas, TX? They ripped me off $127 for what was a $52 seat. Being suspicious, I called the symphony hall box office and spoke with Dan Mayotte, who implied the agency was a consortium of cheap crooks (See their terrible reviews). I petitioned my CC, and they refunded the entire amount, but the SNAFU prevented me from attending the concert of the Schumann piano concerto and Manfred Symphony.
The Falcon
Comment by Peter Lesses — May 16, 2026 at 1:08 pm
Intermission is a time to discuss with friends reaction to the first half of the concert. This is sacred to me and a group of my friends who meet then, over a drink.
Comment by Bettina A. Norton — May 5, 2026 at 12:55 pm
Thank you Toni, and commenters, for a superb article and discussion. Still, I think there is another elephant in the room that needs attention. IMHO, the failure of the BSO Board to consult the musicians and core audience in making the decision to fire Nelsons represents not merely an error, but signifies a massive failure of governance. The implied contempt for musicians and serious music lovers reminds me all too much of the then Boston “elite” at Harvard in pre Yo-Yo Ma years whose view was summed up as “Music is alright as long as it is seen but not heard, and musicians are alright as long as they are heard but not seen.” As a modest BSO “alum” (a season playing for Fiedler in Pops and two as concertmaster of the student orchestra at Tanglewood) who spent most of life as a Professor of Management, I had hoped that the days of old-fashioned views of musicians as labor in an us vs. them labor-management struggle paradigm were over. Alas, it is evidently not so.
Barring a serious attitude, and probably personnel, adjustment on the Board, it is hard to see how musical talent at anything like the current level is going to be attracted to, or likely to stay in—Boston. Who are the people who made this decision? Why are they there? What is the process for appointing them? Are they truly active in building support, or mainly enhancing their own resumes with the institution’s prestige? Is there any check on the Board going the way of so many non-profit, non-public corporations where governance becomes an enclosed bubble; non-responsive to the outside world (or even inside employees) until a crisis hits? I am familiar with only a few of the names of the Trustees, but those seem to come from the worlds of finance and law —with minimal overlap with actual musical playing or scholarship. If the people running an organization don’t actually know much about, or love its activity, does it have a future?
It would be a great service if someone could do a deep dive into the background and process of BSO governance and management…and actually help the BSO articulate an actual vision and plan beyond the current meaningless corporate buzzwords. Perhaps one of our famous management consulting firms could take it on as a pro bono project, as it seems unlikely that the current Board would commission such a review or be inclined to do sufficient self-examination. Otherwise, one can only hope. And as someone famously said, hope is not a strategy.
Comment by Lawrence Franko — March 29, 2026 at 2:08 pm
Mr. Gross is correct that government support is unlikely. Unfortunately, getting butts in seats doesn’t solve a thing. The BSO could sell out every concert and still have a massive operating deficit.
That is the crux of the problem that must be addressed, and I have not heard anyone propose a solution.
No, tapping the endowment won’t solve the problem. 90% of the endowment is in restricted funds that can’t be used to keep the lights on.
Comment by Thomas Dinsmore — March 25, 2026 at 4:40 pm
Good points, which is why I suggest outreach thru’ programs like Project Step and advocate just such visits as you yourself have done. Remember Fantasia??? Show it in schools!
Comment by Bettina A. Norton — March 25, 2026 at 3:30 pm
This was a cogent column about classical music problems in general, but, sadly, irrelevant about the BSO. Schools won’t be teaching more about classical music, the government certainly won’t be supporting the arts any more than they are, and more than likely, less, and I don’t want to seem to be making fun of anyone who calls the box office, but how many people still do that?
The basic problem is, in the colloquial, putting tushies in the seats. It’s hard, especially at the prices needed to pay highly skilled people who live in the Boston area. The board may not want to say it, because it will restrict their search, but what the BSO needs, aside from a great conductor, is someone who will devote him or herself to the BSO and not drop by for a few days between their other orchestras engagements. That means going to many boring fundraising dinners snd meetings with foundations and very rich people with disposable wealth. It means going to schools to meet young people and explain the music to them. I had luck in NYC going to schools and playing things like the last movement of Profofiev’s 7th Piano Sonata because it has a rock and roll sensibility and the Shostakovitch 5th because it shares the sensibility of John Williams’ Star Wars scores. I love Bruckner, and I want to hear it, but I’m not taking the 8th to a school to initially pull young people in to start exploring.
So we need outreach, and we need a conductor who is not only great, but committed to spread the gospel. Despite his many commitments, Dudamel is willing to do that.
We need a music director for whom one orchestra and a summer season is enough. I hate to point this out, but no matter how impressed someone is with it, no record buyers or concert goers care even a little bit about the Grammys.
Comment by Gil Gross — March 25, 2026 at 2:13 pm
re: the presentation by Chad Smith at the Granoff Music Center at Tufts on April 6, a very helpful staff person (a violist, no less) said it was scheduled a while ago, so well before the brouhaha over the BSO mailing. However, we can assume it was planned to spell out BSO’s intended new direction… Would it not have been a good occasion in which to solicit comments before the BSO board set itself on fire?
FYI, Nelsons is scheduled for the very next day, at noon, as the last speaker in the Tufts Music Dept.’s Mahler Sessions….
Comment by Bettina A. Norton — March 25, 2026 at 8:52 am
Thank you for your note. I remember your name…
Tony Fogg was a real asset to the BSO, as your quote attests. Thank you.
Comment by Bettina A Norton — March 24, 2026 at 10:40 pm
I am a former violinist with the Boston Symphony,having joined in 1975. I still occasionally perform with the orchestra at Tanglewood, filling in as needed.
I once asked Tony Fogg, for decades the Vice-president of Artistic Planning until recently stepping down, why the BSO bothered with international concert tours, considering the great expense,the years of organizational planning, and the sometimes grueling schedule of travel, rehearsals, and concerts.
His answer was as revealing as it was succinct: “Because, Jerry, as a nonprofit, the BSO’s goals are mission-based, not financial, so the intangibles take on much greater significance.” In other words, artistry comes first.
That simple concept, in a nutshell, is what the current Boston Symphony management and administration seem either incapable of comprehending or unwilling to embrace.
Comment by Gerald Elias — March 24, 2026 at 9:30 pm
In my days of producing the Symphony Hall BSO broadcasts, I started many a script with Ron Della Chiesa reading:
“From the Fenway Park of music, Symphony Hall in Boston, I’m Ron Della Chiesa…”
I see parallels with the two structures. One can update Fenway Park, but I become very concerned about updates to Symphony Hall, for fear that such updates will compromise the awesome acoustics.
Comment by Brian Bell — March 24, 2026 at 12:13 pm
Ms. Norton has very thoughtfully laid out the issues at hand and I thank her for that. I am especially moved by her anecdote about the Mr. Holland’s Opus program to provide thousands of schoolchildren who otherwise would have been locked out financially an instrument to learn music. Sadly, most exposure to “music” for young people comes through earbuds at deafening audio levels. There is a place for that. But not at Symphony Hall. And I hope that the ephemeral “future vision” on which the BSO board based its lamentable decision to part ways with Maestro Nelson’s does not mean programming that seeks to compete with the earbud repertoire. Just ask the musicians what they see and hear. Please. Ask them. And if the board has any interest in meeting the expectations of its substantial subscriber base and donor pool, it is not too late to reverse course and retain Nelson’s while seeking workable solutions within the BSO and its structure.
Comment by Mary DeGarmo — March 24, 2026 at 12:02 pm
I don’t think I can objectively respond to Mr. Dinsmore‘s comment about Symphony Hall and its problems. He is not wrong and I am a fossil.
Still, I remember my first concert at Symphony Hall in the 70s ending with a performance of Dvořák 8 that lifted me out of my seat. So I have a deep – and sentimental – affection for the hall and find it beautiful, if a bit worn around the edges – and a hallowed space in which to enjoy music. To me it is many things, but not obsolete.
Comment by Michael Beattie — March 24, 2026 at 10:09 am
A few years ago I was travelling and gave my BSO tickets to friends, a highly educated couple who have raised two children. They loved it and one of them said “we felt like adults”. There’s the rub. We don’t live in adult culture anymore. Everything seems geared to twenty somethings, or younger. As a longtime subscriber I am very concerned that this “vision” management cites, and which it has utterly failed to articulate, is some version of this trend.
Comment by BobR — March 24, 2026 at 9:44 am
Publius mentions “so many other wonderful organizations” out there. He is right. I am on the board of two and regularly attend concerts of at least five other fine musical groups in Boston, plus one or two concerts by other groups. We are awash in opportunities to enjoy fine music, which for the most part, is beautifully played.
Again, I repeat, a survey might have revealed how this affects attendance at the BSO.
Comment by Bettina A. Norton — March 23, 2026 at 8:58 pm
DEI strawman logical fallacies for no reason will always be wild and irrelevant.
At any rate, the BSO has had trash marketing and social media for ages and it boggles my mind that the current debacle got pinned on Nelsons when, as the author writes, there are so many more issues. Ticket prices are certainly part of the equation and there should be ways to entice younger peolle to join the culture, such as the Handel and Haydn Society’s H2 mixers.
I am not sure how many people are using the phone services, but the BSO website itself is also trash and consistently crashes and does not work for both myself and my friends when we try to purchase tickets, whoch likewise boggles my mind.
A longer intermission would also be a positive change, though I wonder if this would be feasible. More than anything, the BSO has eroded its trust with its audience and musicians and should firstly try to gain that back. With current management, best of luck with that. I imagine worse developments on the horizon and I fully intend to attend concerts as I see fit and cheer for Andris to voice my displeasure. As for the future, with the Handel and Haydn Society as well as so many other wonderful organizations out there in the Boston area, I will happily explore more at the expense of the BSO past the 2027 season as well as take up private lessons instead.
Comment by Publius — March 23, 2026 at 4:40 pm
Toni has, as usual, penned a wonderful coda for this fiasco. It is, however, time for all of us to move on, briskly, lively and fast, allegro if you will, for a Horatio is not going to from the board or management and take on the burden of explaining their recent “carnal, bloody, and unnatural acts” to the public so it can understand why the royal family just, like, destroyed itself, if you will.
Time to focus on the future and on who shall lead the orchestra and, more importantly, management’s and the board’s plan to address the concern over “the BSO’s direction”. We need to make sure the board and managemnt are not like the “dog who finally caught the car” and have no idea what to do next. What is their plan, now? How will it work? Where have they seen it work? I am sure there was/is a plan and not like a certain current military action, like. For the board and management, the spin is over and, like, it’s time to act.
A few months ago, I, like, attended a performance of Carmen at the Met that featured…ICE agents. The house was more than half empty. No one wants this stuff. If one chooses to linger on the past, before you know it the board will compound its “error” by hiring a music director based on DEI attributes with, like, no consideration given to the things that truly, like, matter.
Chesley
Harvard 1968
BSO Subscriber
Comment by Chesley Basket — March 23, 2026 at 3:20 pm
yes. Harvard’s Houghton Library ran a series of chamber concerts from the late 1970s to early 2000s.
Comment by Bettina A Norton — March 23, 2026 at 1:51 pm
Yes, there are some good seats at Symphony Hall. True, classical aficionados can just close eyes and listen. We can do that at home, for a fraction of the cost.
The visual experience of live symphony is absolutely necessary. Compared to modern halls in LA and Philadelphia, Symphony Hall is obsolete.
Comment by Thomas Dinsmore — March 23, 2026 at 12:15 pm
Bettina Houghton concerts?
Comment by Bennett — March 23, 2026 at 11:32 am
Sight lines? For average to short persons, viewing on the floor is limited to strings. Our family’s seats were are still are first balcony center, now row B, aisle seats. Can’t beat them. But often I close my eyes. My dear departed friend Morton Bradley, who used to take me to Houghton concerts, would often close his eyes, to concentrate on listening, he explained.
Hearing is what counts. A few halls equal, but none beats, our BSO’s.
Comment by Bettina A Norton — March 23, 2026 at 11:02 am
I find it interesting that the author blames “American life” as something that has failed the Symphony. I suspect the opposite is true, that the BSO has simply fallen so far behind our modern society that it is becoming irrelevant.
I point to the mention of “American life” as an example. The US is not “America”, it is OF America. America is composed of North, South and Central America. A tone-deaf lack of inclusiveness turns off the very people you think should be your loyal customers.
Maybe it is time for the BSO to realize that instead of expecting the world to align to its ancient values and practices, it needs to evolve, lest it become as extinct as the Dodo.
Comment by Juan Jimenez — March 23, 2026 at 10:57 am
I’m going to make some people mad by pointing out that Symphony Hall is part of the problem. Most of the balcony seats have poor sightlines. The seating itself is uncomfortable. The neighborhood is dodgy at night, and parking is a science project.
None of this has anything to do with Mr. Nelsons, of course.
Comment by Thomas Dinsmore — March 23, 2026 at 10:31 am
This is really good, and I hope we might hear more about what it was like to attend concerts during the Koussevitzky era (when more subscribers lived within the City of Boston) – both what is better and what is worse in the experience. Additionally Serge Koussevitzky programed the music of Dmitri Shostakovich and Jean Sibelius. Andris Nelsons also programs works by these composers. I hope you may be able to write about and compare your concert experience of these works under both Serge Koussevitzky and Andris Nelsons.
Thank you for your article.
During my high school years, WGBH radio had a program on that aired on Sunday afternoons. It was called The Koussevitzky Legacy. The program began with the theme from Edvard Grieg’s The Last Spring, the last recording Koussevitzky made with the Boston Symphony before he passed. It featured many recordings by the Boston Symphony as well the music critics who covered Koussevitzky. It was programming such as this, as well as C. Wallace Woodworth’s presentations every Thursday at about 9:00 PM, that went over the entire upcoming Boston Symphony concert that taught me much about music. Additionally, there once were three music critics in Boston, one for The Boston Herald, one for The Boston Globe, and one for The Christian Science Monitor, the Monitor critic actually wrote how Erich Leinsdorf was similar but different from Felix von Weingartner, so I learned about Weingartner as well.
Such outreach could now be channeled into pod casts.
Comment by Maurice “Rick” Laurence — March 23, 2026 at 10:27 am
C.W I don’t know about European venues, but I did as you suggested in regard to the Boston Ballet and the Metropolitan Opera. Intermissions at the Boston Ballet seem to be about the same length as that of the Boston Symphony, while those of the Metropolitan Opera appear to be MUCH longer. Of course, we are comparing different art forms. Operas tend to be much longer than symphonic performances; they could be twice as long or sometimes even three times as long. Also, elaborate sets and costumes are common. Extra time may be needed for these technical aspects. Too, singers may want and/or need time to rest their voices between acts.
Comment by Bennett — March 22, 2026 at 10:58 pm
Many people who attend performances primarily for the performances themselves, secondarily go for other elements of experience including a social element. Well managed intermissions can contribute meaningfully to the overall satisfaction of an evening. Consider please the Boston Ballet or the Metropolitan Opera in NYC or any number of leading venues in Europe. Intermissions should not be too brief.
Comment by C. W. Hanson — March 22, 2026 at 10:15 pm
Bettina Your third point is valid. When I learned of the new policy, the ushers with whom I spoke could give me no explanation for the change in policy. However, the sixth one is questionable. The Boston Symphony, of course, wants to make money by selling drinks and snacks at intermission. However, Symphony Hall is a concert venue, not a saloon. If one wants to drink, waiting until after the concert to get a drink makes more sense. The second half is almost always less than an hour. I can’t recall an intermission break at a Boston Symphony concert ever being less than 20 minutes, which should be sufficient to attend to one’s needs. DON’T PURCHASE A DRINK! If you are thirsty or may be thirsty, use a drinking fountain or bring a filled water bottle:).
Comment by Bennett — March 22, 2026 at 8:57 pm