IN: Reviews

BSO Revisits American Icons

by

Andris Nelsons conducts Dvořák (Hilary Scott photos)

As readers know, the Boston Symphony Orchestra has been driven into tumultuous times. That the board has terminated Music Director Andris Nelsons’s contract as of the end of Tanglewood 2027 has sparked outrage from both the musicians and loyal audiences. Under these rather tense conditions, and with the orchestra and most of the audience adorned in supportive red carnations and roses (this reviewer wanted one but did not locate one), soprano superstar Renee Fleming, baritone Thomas Hampson, and the Tanglewood Festival Chorus joined the BSO and Nelsons in a pair of American masterpieces from the late-19th and 20th centuries. This review recollects the concert from Thursday night, at Symphony Hall, while other performances occur on the following Friday and Saturday.

Soprano Fleming, baritone Hampson, and the TFC joined the core BSO along with several additional performers (saxophones and synthesizers) for several scenes from John Adams’s first opera Nixon in China. The concert suite represented the entirety of Act I Scene I (Chinese civilians singing Mao’s Three Main Rules of Discipline, the Landing of the Spirit of ’76, the tarmac getting between Nixon and Chou En Lai, and “News has a kind of mystery!”), Pat Nixon’s second act aria “This is prophetic!,” and the toasts with Nixon’s speech in Act I Scene III. Fleming embodied the melancholy and the positivity of Pat Nixon’s future monologue, stealing the show with a restrained energy that radiated across the hall. The aria itself tends to meander through several ideas, and Fleming stayed with the character throughout. Hampson mostly embodied the spirit of Nixon, more so his paranoia and negative mannerisms like the jowl shaking and using a hankie to pat off sweat; in those moments Nixon materialized before our eyes. The kicker, however, was that the same paranoia covered too much of his quiet hopefulness in the China venture. It felt a little too tempered by revisionist views of Nixon, rather than the libretto’s more nuanced take on an insecure man whose deep-seated mistrust of those around him begins to gnaw at every fiber of his being.

Ironically, since there were only two soloists, the men’s section became Chou En Lai in his brief moments for the first act. Although unusual at first given the collective voice embodying the Chinese prime minister, given how the majority of the act focused on Nixon, the decision worked. Wwithin the ensemble, the guest saxophones fit so well into the texture that they almost disappeared entirely. The classic Adams synthesizers did not overpower the large ensemble. In “This is prophetic!,” the oboes and English horn supported Fleming admirably while sounding far more pronounced than in most ensemble recordings of the opera. This concert version of Nixon in China came across extremely well. Can one hope for more opera from the BSO?

Dvořák’s Symphony No. 9 in E Minor, “From the New World,”came across with small subtleties that highlighted new angles of an otherwise well-trod work. Fully in league with his devoted and attentive players, Nelsons found within the cyclical elements imaginative ways to bring freshness to each modified recapitulation —different yet clearly in accord with earlier iterations. Nelsons brought out especially the woodwind and string colors throughout each section return, highlighting differences between the flutes and clarinets versus oboes and clarinets versus ensemble tutti strings, for example. As the first movement frequently returns to its famous ascending-arpeggio motif, Dvořák brings it back each time with subtle changes in the orchestration; Nelsons emphasized each change masterfully. Robert Sheena imbued the “goin’ Home” English horn solo with a singer’s warmth. He fully embodied the core lower range of the solo while letting the upper noted float sotto voce. The lightning-fast Scherzo and the Finale: Allegro con fuoco crackled with electricity and engagement.

It looks like about 100 seats remain for Saturday night’s performance. Readers should see that they are filled, not only to show our support for Nelsons as conductor, but also to demonstrate support for extremely well-composed American music at a time where America culture needs all the support it can get. This show truly is prophetic.

Ian Wiese is an Associate Professor of Ear Training at Berklee College of Music, Theory and Composition Faculty at New England Conservatory of Music Expanded Education, and an active composer. He is also Artistic Director of the Old Stoughton Musical Society, the oldest continuously operating musical society in the US, founded in 1786.

12 Comments »

12 Comments [leave a civil comment (others will be removed) and please disclose relevant affiliations]

  1. Subscribers (and perhaps other ticket buyers) get an email after every performance asking for comments on how to improve. I don’t know if that is normally used to discuss programming, air temperature in the hall, or just the brand of coffee in the lounge. But I finally did leave a comment after the Adams/Dvorak program. That did produce a nice, if inconclusive letter from someone in customer service. We’ll see how many of these get tabulated and sent to the board. I am a little undecided here– do patrons support the artistic programming as it continues to get better? Or do we sit on wallets to see if Mrs. Hostetter can afford to fulfill her vision single-handed?

    Comment by Concordia — April 5, 2026 at 11:51 am

  2. With respect to airing later, the score apparently did request a bit of electronic help for the singers. There was a control board at the back of the front rows of the orchestra, with a techie actively at work.

    In the hall, the balances seemed OK with just a modest glare from the large loudspeakers. But creating a permanent document that balances the singers’ tracks with those of the rest of the multi-miked orchestra might take a little time.

    Comment by Concordia — April 5, 2026 at 11:46 am

  3. “Thank you for this detailed review, Ian! It’s wonderful to see the BSO tackling both Adams and Dvořák with such energy and nuance. Fleming and Hampson clearly brought their characters to life, and Nelsons’ interpretation of the ‘New World’ Symphony sounds both fresh and insightful. I hope more performances like this get wider recognition and broadcasts so that audiences beyond Symphony Hall can experience it.”

    Comment by Olivia — April 4, 2026 at 9:36 am

  4. And, soloists frequently want to sign off on a performance before it is broadcast.

    I still think my original thought is the correct one – minutes of thunderous applause going out over the airwaves with a description by the host of the mood and goings on at Symphony Hall is probably not what the BSO Board and CEO wanted to happen.

    And, what’s all this gibberish about rebuilding trust, without taking responsibility for breaking the trust? And no plan for rebuilding?

    Comment by Cecilia — March 29, 2026 at 2:26 pm

  5. Ian, That’s a good point about licensing for the Adams pieces. I had not thought of that. Thank you. I wish the BSO press office could have provided some more information!

    Comment by Adam — March 29, 2026 at 7:54 am

  6. Yes, Ian knows that the words came later.

    Comment by Lee Eiseman — March 28, 2026 at 10:47 pm

  7. The “Goin’ Home” text was only added later to Dvořák’s tune by one of Dvořák’s pupils, William Arms Fisher (1861-1948). Fisher adapted and arranged the Largo theme and added his own words, as indicated on the sheet music cover published by Oliver Ditson Company in Boston in 1922. You can read Fisher’s description of his ideas and intention in the 1922 sheet music posted here:
    https://urresearch.rochester.edu/institutionalPublicationPublicView.action?institutionalItemId=18093

    Comment by LDSP — March 28, 2026 at 10:34 pm

  8. Admittedly, it could also have to do with licensing for the Adams pieces. Just another thought.

    Comment by Ian Wiese — March 28, 2026 at 9:25 pm

  9. Ah, Adam…I think the answer to your on-point question is. Hell, yes!

    Comment by Cecilia — March 28, 2026 at 7:27 pm

  10. This is a great concert. Why can’t it be aired live? Is the BSO afraid of allowing it to be broadcast and being embarrassed by the outpouring of support for the orchestra and Maestro Nelsons?

    Comment by Adam — March 28, 2026 at 4:40 pm

  11. “The majority of our concerts air live, but some, like this one, will air at a later date,” according to a BSO source.

    Comment by Lee Eiseman — March 28, 2026 at 11:01 am

  12. Thank you for this great review!
    May I ask why WCRB is not broadcasting this concert live tonight? Is it because of Renee Fleming contract not allowing this?

    Comment by Adam — March 28, 2026 at 9:54 am

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, this comment forum is now closed.