IN: Reviews

Mozart and Sibelius from Nelsons and the BSO

by

Mao Fujita (Robert Torres photos)

I was taken aback to realize that, before Thursday, I hadn’t heard the BSO at Symphony Hall since last May’s season-ending Shostakovich program. The announcement from the orchestra’s Board of Trustees that Andris Nelsons’s tenure as music director will end with the 2027 Tanglewood season reminded us that we shouldn’t take anything for granted. That includes top-tier conducting. 

The program had a northern slant, beginning with Finnish composer Outi Tarkiainen’s Day Night Day and ending with Finnish composer Jean Sibelius’s Symphony No. 1. In between came Mozart’s Piano Concerto No. 21 (K.467), which premiered in Vienna but found broad exposure after Swedish director Bo Widerberg used the Andante in his 1967 film Elvira Madigan. With Japanese pianist Mao Fujita making his BSO debut in the Mozart, it wasn’t exactly a household-name bill. Next Wednesday’s concert, with Lang Lang playing the Grieg Piano Concerto and Nelsons leading Dvořák’s “New World” Symphony, has been sold out for some time now. For this concert, however, Symphony Hall was far from full. I don’t see how one can fault the program. I found little fault in the performances. Perhaps the conjunction of Passover and Holy Thursday played a part. Or perhaps the BSO’s marketing department needs to step up.

The orchestra continued with its new tradition of tuning up onstage, departing, and then entering en masse, in a show of unity and support for Nelsons. That elicited fervent applause Thursday, and it escalated when Nelsons arrived. He was about to cue Day Night Day when an audience member shouted, loud enough to be heard at the back of the hall, “We love you, Andris.” Nelsons turned, smiled, and replied, “We love you, too.” 

Tarkiainen has lived in London and Paris and the USA, but she’s now back in her Arctic Circle birthplace, Rovaniemi. Last year, we heard her Midnight Sun Variations, conducted by the dedicatee, John Storgårds. Day Night Day is a co-commission of the Berlin Philharmonic, the BSO, and the Finnish Radio Symphony Orchestra; it premiered with the Berliners under Marin Alsop in February 2024. The seven-minute piece is a study for Tarkiainen’s next opera commission, Day of Night, which she’s basing on the novel Halla Helle by Sámi author Niillas Holmberg. She describes it as “northern light and ice that every winter invade the land but that reflect the early spring light in brilliant spectra.” The muted-trumpet melody at the beginning draws on a Sámi joik; toward the end, flute and clarinet recall the Sámi lullaby “Sjamma, sjamma.”

Like Midnight Sun Variations, Day Night Day pays tribute to Sibelius’s Tapiola. The piece begins quietly, celesta and harp to start. The clarinets are answered by the flutes, perhaps birds calling to one another in the Finnish taiga. We hear the muted trumpets, then the clarinets and flutes again, their song punctuated by celesta and harp. Shimmering strings sparkle like icy shafts of glittering sunlight. The tempo picks up and roaring brass choirs come to the fore over agitated timpani, with trombone slides suggesting the Northern Lights flickering out of control. Then the flute and clarinet sing their lullaby, and the piece dies out ppp. On Thursday, the individual instruments didn’t emerge as clearly as I expected, at least at the start; the piece whooshed by in a wash of sound. Perhaps the second balcony wasn’t the best spot from which to appreciate Tarkiainen’s ephemeral scoring. The orchestra will repeat Day Night Day Friday afternoon, Saturday evening, next wdnesday, and then next Friday as part of its New York engagement at Carnegie Hall.   

Mozart premiered his K.467 in the spring of 1785, at a time when he was at the height of his popularity in Vienna. Piano Concerto No. 20 (K.466) had debuted just weeks earlier; that one, in D minor, looks ahead to 1787’s Don Giovanni, whereas the sunnier C-major K.467 foreshadows the following year’s Le nozze di Figaro. The march-like opening of the Allegro maestoso, with its trumpets and timpani, suggests Figaro’s prediction of what awaits amorous page Cherubino after he’s dispatched to the Count’s regiment in Seville. Or the music’s stealthy tiptoeing and frequent forays into minor keys could put you in mind of the opera’s many romantic assignations, impersonations, and misrepresentations. The hypnotic Andante could be an aria for Susanna or the Countess. The Allegro vivace assai rondo finale, with its anticipations of the Nozze di Figaro Overture, finds piano and orchestra in hyperdrive; you can practically see Susanna and the Countess dressing up as each other, Figaro and Susanna suspecting each other, everyone stumbling about in the garden at night.

Diana the Huntress, aka Artemis, salutes her namesake astronauts.

Fujita, who’ll turn 28 in November, won the 2017 Clara Haskil Competition and was joint runner-up behind Alexandre Kantorow in the 2019 International Tchaikovsky Competition before making his US solo recital debut at Carnegie Hall in 2023. Boston first heard him this past February in a Vivo Performing Arts recital at Longy School’s Pickman Hall. He’s recorded all 18 of Mozart’s piano sonatas for Sony Classical; his Mozart in general is fresh, exuberant, by turns melting and mischievous.

Mozart wrote the concerto for flute, two oboes, two bassoons, two horns, two trumpets, timpani, and strings; he had clarinets in his operas of this time, but the instrument was still fairly new in 1785 and might not have been available for a house concert. The trumpets and timpani sat out the Andante. For this performance, Nelsons had some 45 strings, about what Philippe Jordan called for when he led the BSO in K.466 a couple of years back. The opening tutti, at a relaxed pace, was both militant and good-humored, and Elizabeth Klein’s solo flute highlighted the second theme. Fujita entered discreetly, with welcome nuance and rubato, neither heaven-storming nor small-scale. He underlined the sudden appearance of G minor in his exposition; he made the piano solo theme sing; he gave heft to the brief development and pointed it toward the recapitulation. He reveled in the virtuosic sections; it’s hard to think Mozart wouldn’t have admired his inhumanly even passagework.

Nelsons and the orchestra provided full-bodied support in what was a spacious, light-hearted first movement until it reached the cadenza. Mozart’s own cadenzas for this concerto have not survived; playing an extended one of his own creation, Fujita exploded in grand Lisztian fury, thundering through first the piano solo theme and then the main theme for some four minutes, giving a new dimension to the movement.

The Andante wasn’t quite as successful. Nelsons set a relatively swift pace, not at all inappropriate for the tempo marking, the orchestra more passionate than reflective, but at the outset Fujita needed to be more assertive. He did better exploring the second theme, with its chromatic modulations, spinning out more immaculate passagework. The rondo finale might have been more boisterous, but Fuijita was in his element playing hide-and-seek with the orchestra, finding a poignant simplicity in the first episode’s closing theme and pointing up the second episode’s hesitant A-minor entrance.

As an encore, he gave us the least virtuosic selection imaginable: Liszt’s transcription of Mozart’s Ave Verum Corpus motet. He made a prayer of the piece, taking an extremely slow tempo, each note weighted, inflected, carillon-like. It was hypnotic; I was left hoping he would give us a second encore and play it again.

Sibelius composed his First Symphony in 1899, and it got its BSO premiere just eight years later. Up through Serge Koussevitzky’s tenure as music director, the piece was popular with Boston audiences; in number of BSO Sibelius symphony performances, it still ranks only behind No. 2. Yet it’s been losing ground over the past 80 years. Before Thursday, the orchestra hadn’t presented No. 1 in Symphony Hall since 1991, and Nelsons is now the first BSO music director to lead it here since Koussevitzky in 1945. 

Given the obvious influences of Tchaikovsky and Dvořák and Bruckner, you could argue the composer didn’t really get his feet stuck in Finnish soil till No. 2. All the same, No. 1 is cut from the same cloth as his Kullervo and Four Legends. The symphony begins with 16 measures of rune-singing solo clarinet over rolling timpani, and when the timpani breaks off, the clarinet continues for another 12 measures, as if the Kalevala were beginning, Väinämöinen emerging from the scaup egg, a tale older than time. The key is E minor, which does not bode well.

What follows might be the story of Kullervo, who unknowingly sleeps with his sister, after which they both commit suicide. It might be the story of Ilmarinen and Väinämöinen and Lemminkäinen and their unnumerable unsuccessful quests for a bride from the North (a theme Sibelius would revisit in Pohjola’s Daughter). Whatever, it’s heroic and tragic. The two big subjects of the opening movement strive to achieve G major. The E-flat-major Andante begins as a lullaby, perhaps sung by Lemminkäinen’s mother as she’s piecing him back together after his misadventures in Tuonela. Birds chirp over warning timpani; the sleeper’s dream turns into a racing nightmare before the lullaby returns as if nothing had happened. The scherzo, with its drumming syncopated timpani rhythm, finds Lemminkäinen on the run from Louhi mistress of the North; the finale begins with the strings taking up that opening clarinet meditation, admitting, “You told us but we didn’t listen.” The timpani rumbles ominously throughout; Vic Firth’s stellar playing is a highlight of the 1976 BSO recording with Colin Davis.

The pioneering recording of the First, made by Robert Kajanus with the London Symphony in 1930, clocks in at just under 35 minutes. Osmo Vänskä matched that in his 1996 recording with the Lahti Symphony, but in general, performances of Sibelius, like those of Bruckner and Mahler, have been getting slower. Given some of his recent expansive readings, I thought Nelsons might approach the 43 minutes of Leif Segerstam’s 1992 recording with the Danish National Symphony, but at 38 minutes, this was a tumultuous, fire-and-ice First with a vehement contribution from timpanist Timothy Genis.

William R. Hudgins did get plenty of room for that opening solo, and he took full advantage; Nelsons stood motionless on the podium, seemingly transfixed, as Hudgins’s brooding clarinet spun a mesmerizing spell. The Allegro energico first subject surged with warm brass; the second found flutes, oboes, and clarinets dancing in harmony; the development brought first apocalyptic fanfares from the brass and then two intimate solo violins in the second subject. Sibelius finds various ways to express the Kalevala heroes’ frustrations: the exposition stops rather than finishes; the development picks up speed but never gets anywhere; the recapitulation materializes rather than starts. Nelsons conveyed all this with precise paragraphing, bringing the recapitulation’s first subject to a glowing G-major peak before it crashed in E minor. Hudgins’s clarinet then reminded us the second subject was due to meet the same fate. The movement ends with two chords from harp and pizzicato strings; Nelsons took care to have them played f in anticipation of the finale.    

The Andante sighed gently, sorrowfully, not too slow and not too heavy-footed, Nelsons observing Sibelius’s Un poco meno Andante direction for the woodwind fugue. The Molto tranquillo middle section, with its horns and swirling harp and frisky woodwinds, was building to an optimistic conclusion when it got cut off by the return of the lullaby, now leaden and anguished. That led to the racing nightmare, Sibelius marking the tempo to double, and then the sleeper roused by the lullaby, once again tender, Nelsons adhering to Sibelius’s Allargando marking in drawing out the final bars.

Genis’s timpani set the tone for a quick, pounding Scherzo. Here too, sections just stop; the trio starts up after the main section runs out of ideas. Lorna McGhee’s bright flute solo promised a respite until a trill from Hudgins’s clarinet prompted some minor-key reflections from the horns and a sober Bruckner modality from the strings. The main section, when it returned, was truncated by a violent Stretto.

Nelsons saved plenty of fireworks for the Finale. The strings expressed a hopeless resignation in their recollection of the symphony’s clarinet opening; the woodwinds seemed to nod in agreement, the horns answering with an “I told you so.” The Kalevala heroes set off nonetheless at an Allegro molto, undaunted by a roadblocking four-note motif and halted only by a painful descent in the violins that Nelsons gave his full attention. Redemption is promised by the glorious Andante assai second subject, where Nelsons, unlike many conductors, created a clear contrast without being too slow or growing sentimental. Redemption is illusory: the music begins to speed up and fall apart at the same time. Sibelius repeats the sequence: Nelsons built the Allegro molto to an orgiastic climax, only for the four-note roadblock to reappear. Richard Sebring’s solo horn led the return of the second subject, which Nelsons made even more resplendent, as if to disguise the fact that it’s in B major rather than the proper G major and thus doomed to fail. The E-minor coda went Piú largamente poco a poco as marked, with the roadblock, now drawn out, crashing in a third time, almost as if anticipating the original three hammer blows of Mahler’s Sixth Symphony. The Finale, like the opening movement, concludes with two pizzicato chords, but these are marked mf and then p, and Nelsons made the distinction. If the orchestra’s Board of Trustees thinks Sibelius of this quality will be easy to replicate with a different conductor, it should think again.

Jeffrey Gantz has been writing about music, dance, theater, art, film, and books for the past 45 years, first for the Boston Phoenix and currently for the Boston Globe.

8 Comments »

8 Comments [leave a civil comment (others will be removed) and please disclose relevant affiliations]

  1. Regarding Jeffrey Gantz review of the Mao Fujita performance of the Mozart K.467, he wrote, “Mozart’s own cadenzas for this concerto have not survived; playing an extended one of his own creation, Fujita exploded in grand Lisztian fury, thundering through first the piano solo theme and then the main theme for some four minutes, giving a new dimension to the movement.” While I only heard the broadcast of this performance, I thought it a most tasteless and inappropriate cadenza for this concerto and Mozart traditions. One need only listen to a multitude of fine pianists perform this piece–an endless list–to be startled by the inappropriate cadenza we heard by Fujita.

    Comment by WAyne WIld — April 7, 2026 at 2:25 pm

  2. @James Robert Cassady,MD — I have talked to hundreds of people outside of Symphony Hall recently, and the people I have spoken to are 97 – 99% in favor of Andris Nelsons and BSO musicians. This is not even an exaggeration. So many people are still outraged and disgusted; many being long term subscribers who have told me they are done with the BSO at this point and may just go to particularly interesting concerts, or even abandon the BSO altogether as a a protest and dig into other local musical organization. I get it.

    At this point, I don’t understand why there has not been more media coverage with regular subscribers or even casual concert goers who attend at least a few concerts every year. The initial shock has faded, but the love for Andris Nelsons has only started blooming and the louds cheers will only continue. It seems like the media has closed up shop after the initial outrage and figured it is a done deal, which is a shame. Wednesday’s concert is sold out and the crowd will go crazier than ever for Andris.

    Comment by Publius — April 5, 2026 at 8:51 pm

  3. As I have said in an earlier note to the BSO Trustee Board, do YOUR job. 30 + people on marketing and this is what we get-an unfilled hall. The problem is Chad Smith and Barbara Hostetter, not our super conductor.Virtually all of the “problems” listed by the Board are Trustee Based problems not Nelsons. Do everything possible to keep Nelsons and fire immediately Smith and Hofstetter and there will be a great YEA from all of Boston. Keep these two and cry at the destruction of one of Boston’s great treasures. Robert Cassady,MD

    Comment by James Robert Cassady,MD — April 5, 2026 at 4:30 pm

  4. Oh Brava Beverly Sky !!

    Comment by Martin Snow — April 5, 2026 at 9:00 am

  5. There is a saying in Japan…”ishi no ue nemo, san nen” (Even sitting on a rock, three years, i.e.even doing nothing, takes three years to get good at it!)
    The Sibelius performance by Nelsons and orchestra last night was an astonishing theatrical experience. We were swept up and released, swept up and released by the music by powerful waves of sonoric beauty. Nelsons was conducting the entire audience! I have to think that perhaps the powers that be at the BSO have NOT attended his masterclass conducting performances! How do you fire a genius who is so at one with his musicians and is not even at his peak? It takes more than three years to build the kind of trust and… yes, love that he is able to elicit from this distinguished cohort.
    It’s like the Red Sox giving away their best players! Nelsons is a Boston treasure. Tie him to the podium. Don’t let him go.

    Comment by Beverly Sky — April 5, 2026 at 7:54 am

  6. Jeffrey Gantz: “If the orchestra’s Board of Trustees thinks Sibelius of this quality will be easy to replicate with a different conductor, it should think again.”

    So true. If you’re out there, Chad Smith and Barbara Hostetter, please think again, and then again!

    Comment by nimitta — April 4, 2026 at 4:59 pm

  7. Inspired by the season I’ve been listening this week to the off the air recording I made of the Nelsons/BSO March 2019 performance of Dvorak’s Stabat Mater. This performance was surely one of the highlights of Nelsons’ tenure here in Boston. It was also a high point for the Tanglewood Festival Chorus and it got me to wondering whether or not, in light of recent events, we should be asking more questions about last summer’s abrupt and unexplained exit by choral director James Burton.

    Comment by jim47895 — April 3, 2026 at 4:39 pm

  8. BSO abysmal marketing and social media game is absolutely that blame for any lack of attendance and it boggles my mind what they even do, especially the marketing department. However, the lack of Andris Nelsons in the advertising does, sadly, make sense to me now.

    Now more than ever, people are showing up for the BSO musicians and Andris Nelsons, not due to any marketing.

    Comment by Publius — April 3, 2026 at 4:00 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, this comment forum is now closed.