IN: Reviews

Brisk Beethoven, Agile Adams at Symphony Hall

by

Boston Symphony Orchestra at Symphony Hall, Thursday, April 30, 2026, in Boston. (Photo by Winslow Townson)
Dima Slobodeniouk,, conductor (Winslow Townson photo)

Guest conductor Dima Slobodeniouk and the Boston Symphony Orchestra provided a rare and intriguing opportunity to hear John Adam’s early masterpiece Harmonium, followed by Beethoven’s Ninth Symphony. The Tanglewood Festival Chorus, ably prepared by guest choral conductor Jean-Sébastien Vallée enlivened the performances, which marked the end of the Orchestra’s 2025-26 season. Thursday’s program recurs Friday afternoon, Saturday evening, and Sunday afternoon.

John Adams wrote Harmonium early in his career in 1980. It, andShaker Loops from 1978, were his first major works for orchestra. Their arrival marked the appearance of an impressive new voice in American music. Indeed, Harmonium still rings true as a genuine breakthrough work, sounding as fresh today as it must have to its audience at its San Francisco Symphony Orchestra premiere over 44 years ago.

Adams had intended to set the verse of Wallace Stevens, but early on encountered difficulty in finding a comfort level with that poet’s language and rhythmic sense. In a revealing note that appears in the BSO program book, Adams writes:

I cast far and wide for a text to satisfy a musical image that I had in mind. That image was one of human voices — many of them — riding on waves of rippled sound. I ultimately settled on three poems of transcendental vision. “Negative Love” by John Donne examines the qualities of various forms of love, ascending in the manner of Plato’s Symposium, from the carnal to the divine. I viewed this “ascent” as a kind of vector, having both velocity and direction…The two (Emily) Dickinson poems show the polar opposites of her poetic voice. “Because I Could Not Stop For Death” is the intimate, hushed Dickinson…a kind of pastoral elegy expressed through the lens of a slow-motion camera…”Wild Nights” (is) the other side of Emily Dickinson, saturated with an intoxicated, ecstatic, pressing urge to dissolve herself in some private and unknowable union of eros and death.

With such pithy substance it is no wonder that Harmonium packs an almost visceral power to move and enchant its listeners. Early on one hears the pulse of repeated notes and words that later came to be called “minimalism,” but there is nothing minimal in Adams’s extraordinary settings of these far-ranging and emotional texts. His is among the most moving musical settings of Dickinson’s words, especially telling when the composer colors the arrival of the word “Immortality,” with sepulchral strokes of bass drum and tam-tam. Equally moving is Adams’s shimmeringly diaphanous scoring heard when accompanying the poet’s telling description of a funeral cortege with “…I first surmised the Horses’ Heads were toward Eternity —”

Harmonium abounds with energy and brilliant writing for chorus and orchestra, and Slobodeniouk led a performance which offered a clear exposition of this remarkable music’s many rhythms and colors. Only once or twice did I detect what might have been a few opening night ensemble jitters that will surely disappear in subsequent performances. Though I prefer a bit less soft-edged interpretation such as can be heard in Edo de Waart’s dynamic and powerful San Francisco Symphony recording, it was a pleasure to hear the BSO’s embrace of this very moving music in the acoustic excellence of Symphony Hall.

After intermission Beethoven’s Ninth Symphony received a vigorous and fleet performance, the quickest read of this music I have heard. All on stage rose to the occasion, though there were moments in the music’s exposition that betrayed a bit of discomfort with the speed of Slobodeniouk’s interpretation. He and the BSO had assembled a notable solo quartet, all of whom brought accuracy and pleasurable singing to their varied roles. Morris Robinson, bass, mightily intoned his introductory paragraph, notably off-book here and throughout the ensuing music. Tenor Andrew Haji was impressive with his vigorous involvement in the Turkish March, and both Zoie Reams, mezzo-soprano and Andrea Carroll, soprano sang lustrously and enthusiastically. The Tanglewood Festival Chorus once again proved that they virtually “own” their significant role in this music, singing fervently with robust tone.

I was a bit unnerved with Slobodeniouk’s constantly forward-moving energy throughout this variegated score. While it was a revealing reading at this speed — I was especially impressed with the second movement’s vitality and rhythmic spring, abetted by Timothy Genis’s lively timpani punctuations, as well as the notable cohesion of the third movement’s beautiful lyrical expression — I found myself longing for just a moment or two of lingering calm. At the Symphony’s end, I, along with most of the audience, was exhilarated, but I admit to ultimately feeling a bit of exhaustion with this interpretation’s almost relentless drive.

So, another chapter of the BSO storied Symphony Hall history closes, not without some anxiety for the Orchestra’s future. Many in the Tanglewood Festival Chorus wore red flowers in solidarity with Music Director Andris Nelsons, as did many in the audience. Alle Menschen werden Brüder is a noble sentiment, surely challenged by events here and abroad. One hopes that virtue, ultimately, will prevail. Concerts by our BSO immensely help encourage optimism in these difficult times. May this cherished ensemble continue to inspire everyone’s better angels.

Founder and Music Director Emeritus John Ehrlich retired from The Spectrum Singers in May, 2024 after 44 years at the helm. He has been a singer and conductor in the Boston area for more than 49 years.
Andrea Carroll, soprano; Zoie Reams, mezzo-soprano; Andrew Haji, tenor; Morris Robinson, bass; Tanglewood Festival Chorus (Winslow Townson photo)

1 Comment »

1 Comment [leave a civil comment (others will be removed) and please disclose relevant affiliations]

  1. The standout of the night for me was Harmonium by Adams and I have come to absolutely adore Nixon and China along with Harmonium work this year due to the 2025 – 2026 season, which I attribute to Andris Nelsons’ programming and the Tanglewood Festival Chorus being the most amazing chorus in the USA, if not the world, as well as Symphony Hall and its acoustics.

    Beethoven’s 9th was likewise wonderful, especially, again, due to the Tanglewood Festival Chorus, great soloists but especially Morris Robinson, who was a real standout of talent.

    I also want to thank Symphony Hall and every part of the Boston Symphony Orchestra organization except for leadership at all levels for what they do for a wonderful performance at Symphony Hall and really recognize them. Such a concert is a lot of work between staging, ushers, lights, running the box office. The BSO is a very wonderful and talented organization despite its current leadership.

    Regarding pace, I do agree that the pacing was unlike Andris Nelson’s performance last year, which I greatly enjoyed as the cap to the Beethoven cycle. Either way, like I said, Harmonium was the star od the show and its ability to build tension

    I was happy to see nearly all musicians on stage wearing a red rose across the BSO, Tanglewood Festival Chorus, and on Dima Slobodeniouk.

    Comment by Publius — May 2, 2026 at 9:40 am

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, this comment forum is now closed.