IN: Reviews

Ever Thrilling, Gripping, Boston Camerata

by

MaKayla McDonald singing (Hilary Scott photos)

How, then, do we the people, tasked with defending our liberties, improving our union, and alerting each other to dangers, communicate our concerns and cultivate courage?

Thursday night’s concert by the Boston Camerata at Tanglewood’s Seiji Ozawa Hall featured a fantastically brilliant program of early American songs grappling with the challenges of our then young Republic. The thrilling beauty of the music vied with the gripping power of the content. Patiently put together by Artistic Director Anne Azema and Music Director emeritus Joel Cohen, “Free America! Early Songs of Resistance and Rebellion” unfolded organically through five “chapters” that led us to revisit our American roots but also brought us face-to-face with our urgent present predicament. As bold as Sam Adams ever was, Anne Azema proclaimed that the concert aimed at kindling our resolve against despair “about the present.”   

Speaking truth to power? Recent research tells us that singing improves blood flow to the small veins, reduces cortisol associated with high blood pressure, and improves breathing. Bass-baritone Phillip Bullock opened the evening with a rich and compelling solo rendering of the Shaker hymn O Zion Arise, retrieved from antebellum Kentucky and proclaiming that “here Liberty reigns as the standard of union, and all are invited” regardless of “colors and nations.” Standing alone as though facing masked and ruthless thugs through the sheer power of conviction, Bullock’s solitary voice, denouncing racism, “slander and envy” as “idols” destroying  democracy, summoned an energized collective response in the form of a spirited fife and drum-led march onto stage of a 15 patriot version of Yankee Doodle Dandy – resurrecting the triumphant entrance of the patriots into Boston in March 1776, when they appropriated the contemptuous song of British tyrants against them as a new badge of honor for the common man!  

The first “chapter” focused on the patriots’ thirst for freedom. The highlight in my view was the ravishing duet of The Liberty Tree by soprano MaKayla McDonald and alto Deborah Rentz-Moore. They imbued the lyrics (by Thomas Paine) with a deep sensitivity for nature, rooted in English folksong. The haunting harmony of their marvelously pure but soaring voices succeeded in turning sturdy timber into a vaster, more eloquent symbol of all that is fragile and green, tender and worth protecting.

Protection comes with fife and drum, adrenaline and courage, but also sacrifice and loss of life. After arousing our resolve with Free America! (based on lyrics by Bunker Hill martyr Joseph Warren) and the very hymnodic Chester (by William Billings), we turned to Chapter 2 and the willingness to die in defense of democracy. Anne Azema joined the other three female vocalists for a very poignant version of the traditional Anglo-Irish lament Johnny is Gone for a Soldier. As though evoking Johnny’s battalion, an instrumental march ensued, The Cuba March combined with The New Union March, nicely punctuated by percussionist Kyle Forsthoff, whose versatile command of all things clacking and clapping, thumping and beating, delighted us throughout. Intoning the sea-shanty Jolly Soldier alone for the first stanza before being joined in its harmonized version by his male co-singers, tenor Ryan Lustgarten conveyed the distinctly jaunty courage of the landless and the disposable, finding truth and meaning in George Washington; a theme reinforced by tenor Daniel Hershey in Saw you my hero George (reminding us of the many baby boys who were named “George Washington” in the wake of the Treaty of Paris, including the only son and heir of Gilbert du Motiers, Marquis de La Fayette). A spirited instrumental, Boston March (1790), brightened into a cheerful proclamation of gentle self-belief by Eric Martin’s fiddle and Andrew Koutroubas’s nicely rustic cello, then the whole choir joined for a powerful rendering of the hymn-like David’s Lamentation by William Billings — honoring the battlefield dead. “O Absalom, my son, my son!” (Alex Pretti, and the young fathers who have recently been gunned down by ICE came to mind).

Johnny’s death at Saratoga or Yorktown brought us to “Chapter 3, Repentance.” From Prince William’s March (where Forsthoff’s drum mimicked horses hooves on cobbled streets) to the closing Shaker hymn that was hauntingly interpreted by Deborah Renz-Moore, this section sang of anti-slavery. It opened with a breath-taking solo interpretation of the Slave Song My Body Rock ‘Long Fever by bass Joel Frederiksen, spilling both anguish and faith into the night. It grew to a high peak with the spiritual Didn’t my Lord Deliver Daniel, masterfully led by Bullock, who introduced rhythm to show how song becomes contagious by engaging the whole body in a new kind of appeal to the heart. The audience could not refrain from joining in, all reticence and self-consciousness eschewed by the collective humanity being deployed for a greater good.

Abolitionism brought us naturally to the challenge of economic inequality. “Chapter 4, Rich and Poor,” grappled with the experience of our ever-precarious underclass through five songs, including an instrumental Scottish jig, The Jolly Beggar:  virtuoso fiddling by Eric Martin and Forsthoff regaling us with yet another percussive dimension of his repertoire on the castanet-like wooden spoons. The section culminated with a fantastically successful full-choir harmonization of Greenwich (1785) praising moral wealth and stature over gold. The final Chapter of “Free America!” focused on energizing us for the struggle ahead by making Freedom, Community, Justice and Truth irresistible, beguiling, uplifting and indispensable. Entitled “Columbia: An Angel”, it enlisted an exuberant but tenderly cheerful instrumental work , The Appletree, along with two Shaker works, including a boldly whimsical dance sung to nonsense lyrics (Gertrude Stein would have loved it)  to fortify our ordinary citizen, common man and woman spirits permanently, annealing us like cognac to fight tyranny yet again. Three secret resources came to the fore: self-confidence in our momentum (Rise Columbia!) individual commitment to the greater good by each and every one of us (Friendly Union, joyfully interpreted by Anne Azema) and, above all, a sense of humor to hold us through thick and thin until we recover our way: “Yankee Doodle, Ha ha ha! Freedom’s voice is in the song.” Indeed we hear new songs of protest and rebellion arising from all corners of the country — including the fusion blues-soul-rock-country tune Rakin’ in his ill-gotten gains composed and interpreted by the Susan Ruel Band in a NY honky-tonk last weekend. You win, Anne Azema! Despair is gone. No Kings then, No Kings now.

Anne Davenport is a scholar of early modern theology and philosophy. She has published books on medieval theories of infinity and Descartes. Her most recent book is “Suspicious Moderate” on the life and works of the 17th-century English Franciscan, Francis à Sancta Clara.

Comments Off on Ever Thrilling, Gripping, Boston Camerata