
Is it possible for first-rate musicians to set their extraneous differences aside for the space of an evening and simply delight in playing music together? When Esa-Pekka Salonen stepped up to the podium at Tanglewood’s Koussevitzky Shed Friday night, he was greeted by BSO musicians wearing red roses on their summer whites, silently affirming their support for their own cherished and now demoted conductor Andris Nelsons. How would it go?
Opening the night with the Prelude and Liebestod from Wagner’s Tristan and Isolde, Salonen and the BSO musicians performed in surprising accord to create a mournful, beautifully roaming Tristan theme, with delicately shaped curtains of grief welling up into the air, expressive and nuanced. Salonen displayed his predilection for clean contours, with elegant phrasing and distinctive use of silences for impact. Although Salonen seemed a bit aloof, eschewing all chumminess, he elicited beautiful sound from the orchestra and did not overcontrol it. The orchestra seemed compliant, but not enthusiastic. Salonen built up the Liebestod gradually to a peak, urging flute and trombones to add a note of fatalism and allotting a prominent role to the harp in achieving a coherent transfiguration of erotic desire into soft glory.
Celestial perfection or sublime sterility? When Wagner wrote to Liszt of his Tristan and Isolde project, he admitted that he had never personally experienced the happiness of shared love. Appropriating Wagner’s novel musical ideas, and indeed citing Wagner’s Tristan theme verbatim at the onset of his Symphony No. 7, Jean Sibelius redirected Wagner’s cult of death into a life-affirming praise of his own conjugal journey with his wife Aino: full of imperfection, strife and compromises, but magnificent in its organic splendor and fertility. Opening the Adagio with a Wagnerian rumbling of timpani evoking the irrepressible emergence of erotic desire, Salonen quickly subverted Wagner’s longing for perfection into a wistful trust in earthly happiness by adding an underlying note of hope through lively bassoons. Upright and undemonstrative, Salonen hid the Aino theme somewhat in the strings, as though a wedding night marked only the first- and less-important consummation of many deeper and more fulfilling ones to come.
Appearing more lively in the Vivacissimo -Adagio section, Salonen brought out the full novelty of Sibelius’s idea of composing a continuous unfolding symphony as a single unbroken movement. The guest conductor gave the second reprise of the Aino theme a tinge of brassy drama above marvelous orchestral skittering, pulling all of the sections of the orchestra briefly together. Graduating seamlessly into Allegro molto moderato, Salonen drew forth a pastoral sound evoking the modestly hidden but subtly sublime achievement of quotidian family life. We traverse, Sibelius implies, successive realms of delight, conflict, reconciliation, joy, anguish and stability. The complex Vivace-Presto-Adagio finale mirrored and reinforced the organic feeling of multiple moods and states growing out of each other and leading to a fulfilling dynamic equilibrium. Salonen built up the tension to a coherent climax with good balance among the orchestral sections, unfurling the Aino theme at last in its poignant triumph over the destructiveness of our megalomaniac selves. The consummation of erotic desire, Sibelius seems to proclaim in his Symphony 7, is not in any narcissistic and sterile Love of Death but in LiebesLeben, our capacity to stick with life and love each other through thick and thin. Thomas Mann, also following WWI, came to a similar rejection of a Germanico-Wagnerian cult of Death, embracing life and its vicissitudes as our genuine human project.
Who needs sex if one has a piano, an orchestra and one is named Ludwig? A venerable but vigorously upright Yefim Bronfman joined Salonen and the BSO for Beethoven’s great feast of erotic sublimation, Piano Concerto No. 5 in E-flat Major, Opus 73, “Emperor.” Plagued by erotic longing but aware by 1811 that he would likely remain unmarried forever, Beethoven poured his titanic desire and violence into his art, sublimating his whole being into a new kind of ecstatic, artistic consummation. Salonen and Bronfman seemed to communicate telepathically, and together, they created a surprisingly fresh interpretation. Shifting the center of gravity of the concerto to the second movement Adagio, they deliberately postponed the ecstatic experience that is usually unleashed in the opening Allegro.

Bronfman took the opening cadenzas with a light, smooth touch, keeping the sound thoughtful, personal, while the orchestra sounded bold, assertive. Using silences and interesting phrasing, Salonen and Bronfman kept the piano meditative throughout, letting the orchestra dominate. Despite some discordance in the winds and brass during the Recapitulation, Bronfman remained controlled and almost prosaic in the last cadenza, yet he elevated the piano to the orchestra’s level.
All of the ecstasy denied us in the Allegro emerged rhapsodically in the Adagio un poco mosso. With a soft, expanding sound emerging from the depth of his heart, Bronfman turned the hymn-like feeling into an inner sanctum. He brought us right into the holy of holies, to be initiated into the most intimate, protracted experience of inner illumination and fulfillment imaginable. Wow. With Salonen using expert pacing in support of Bronfman’s unfolding of ineffable and seemingly unending pleasure, we were ourselves initiated into the strange human paradox that Art fulfills more deeply and more extensively because it fulfills desire without abating it, reviving it more intensely with every increment of sublimation. What a discovery!
Salonen and Bronfman took the finale Rondo, which is typically imbued with a sense of mad joy and exhilaration, at a decidedly “ma non troppo” allegro tempo. Far from making it irresistible, the BSO kept it earth-bound through standard playing, refusing to let rapturous happiness erupt. Did they mean to imply that the rapture of artistic creativity coexists with the prosaic daily work of craftsmanship that is required to shape inspiration into an actual concerto? Or did Salonen and Bronfman recognize that the BSO musicians were simply not ready to overcome the distress that has plagued them in the last months and to let go of it and join them in celebrating Beethoven’s true Immortal Beloved, the music?
Like composers, musicians are human, all-too-human, susceptible to moods, ups and downs, rainy days as well as moments of genius. As though to make a point, Bronfman encored impressively with Liszt’s dazzling test of finger dexterity, the second of Liszt’s Six Grandes Etudes de Paganini. We cannot force Time to suspend its flight, we must live with decay, we must inhabit the cracks of our own human institutions. Yet Beethoven reminds us that beauty, like grace, provides us with ever renewed and inexhaustible consummation, much as we do not deserve it.
Leon Golub is an astrophysicist at the Center for Astrophysics in Cambridge and has been a lover of classical music for over 50 years.

I never felt that Salonen and the BSO—or even Boston itself—was a good match, either in their pursuit of sound or in their musical aspirations and approach to the classical repertoire. Salonen thrives on space and audiences that allow him to incorporate contemporary elements into his concerts, but Boston’s silver-haired audiences show little interest in such experimentation. Sonically, the BSO tends toward a heavier, more solid sound, while Salonen favors a more delicate, chamber-like clarity. For these reasons, the partnership never seemed quite right.
Comment by jo tumma — August 21, 2026 at 2:06 am
After reading this review, I just can’t get the name Dr. Sigmund Freud out of my mind. I wonder why.
Comment by Ewmb — August 2, 2026 at 5:06 pm
That Wagner concert, Tristan Act 2 with Nylund and Kaufmann, I do remember well. It was a let down. I sat in the middle section of the Second Balcony – and barely heard Kaufmann.
Comment by EEwmb — August 2, 2026 at 5:03 pm
“The orchestra seemed compliant but not enthusiastic.” Understandably so.
Salonen may well have been the indirect trigger man for Nelsons’s dismissal. He stepped down from the SFO due to artistic differences, inspiring Chad Smith to emulate him and claim similar differences with Nelsonsʻs artistic vision. Also, Salonen has never spoken out in solidarity for Nelsons, perhaps fearing that such support could erode his own comfortably tailored contract with the LA Philharmonic.
Other conductors like Simon Rattle came out in public support of Nelsons as did many leading orchestras such as the Berlin Philharmonic, Vienna Philharmonic, the Chicago Symphony Orchestra and Cleveland Orchestra, the MET Orchestra, and the Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra. Lang Lang and Evgeny Kissin also spoke on behalf of Nelsons.
I have never been a fan of Salonen from the early days of his career in the 1980s. Iʻm still not a fan of his now. Boulez fits more my taste of a modern conductor, though I prefer Karajan, Solti, Abbado, Muti, Haitink, Sinopoli, Thielemann, Jansons, Bykchov, Ozawa, Celibidache, Mehta, and more recently Nelsons. Salonen was never even on my radar. As for composers, there are many more notable ones than Salonen. (e.g. Paert, Penderecki, Ligeti, Lutoslawski, Glass).
I know my preferences may be subjective but when many people share them, as is the case with the dissenting audience and the orchestra of the BSO, they take on some factual objectivity, particularly when it comes to Andris Nelsons and his inspiring presence here in Boston. I heard Nelsons perform excerpts from Tristand with the BSO in 2018 (reviewed on BMint by Jeffrey Gantz https://classical-scene.com/2018/04/06/wagner-bso/) and there was no lack of enthusiasm on behalf of the orchestra, the performers, and the audience.
Comment by NDA — August 1, 2026 at 8:41 pm