
Tanglewood’s first ever complete performance of Mozart’s Le nozze di Figaro on Saturday night brought together a stellar cast of singers, a joyous opera-pit-sized BSO, and a subtly subversive Andris Nelsons, determined to immerse us in the sheer power and beauty of Mozart’s score. The result was an unmitigated delight with profound undertones. More intimate and more intimately musical than fully staged opera productions, Nelsons’s Nozze was nothing short of transformative.
Nelsons emphasized key ideas in the overture without abrogating its surface love of spectacle and fun. He deliberately created a spirited but deeply civil Age of Enlightenment atmosphere, untouched by the future rumblings of Beethovenian thunder. Carefully shaping orchestral colors and elevating the strings to a distinctive level of loveliness, Nelsons intimated that we should expect to hear individual voices come together without loss of their individual perspective. Wisdom would emerge from tears, bad decisions would be reversed through interpersonal feeling and dialogue. Rich and poor, young and old, lovers and enemies would learn to adjust their feelings to each other’s and to the reality of a shared space. Premiered in Vienna in May 1786, midway between the Treaty of Paris and the Fall of the Bastille, Mozart and Da Ponte condensed Beaumarchais’s play into a new kind of musical masterpiece in which music and action are indivisibly fused, blossoming in a world where reason still had a chance.
With staging shrewdly directed by James Darrah Black, the plot unfolded effortlessly. A magnificently sympathetic, gritty, flawed and inventive Figaro (bass-baritone Michael Sumuel) joined an irresistibly girlish, adorable but self-possessed Susanna (soprano Nikola Hillebrand) to open Act I with beautiful singing and acting. Nelsons vanished into the orchestra to cede the stage to their eloquent interaction. Supporting their duet with nuanced brio, he used strings and winds to enhance the dialogical relationship of the two betrothed, turning the orchestra into commentary rather than mere accompaniment. Dennis Giauque on harpsichord nicely grounded the scene in the humanistic scale of its 18th-century context. Figaro delivered a striking “Se vuol ballare” with contained rage smoldering under the resolve to enjoy scheming against Almaviva’s despicable abuse of power. Set against Figaro’s brave resolve to stand up to power, Bartolo’s “la vendetta!” (bass-baritone Patrick Carfizzi) came off as a comical manifesto of dysfunctional feudal culture, with a rising middle-class wielding law instead of a sword. Marcellina (mezzo-soprano Elizabeth Bishop) was terrific. She embodied the full personality of an aging beauty now fussing over her social status, covering a basically warm-hearted nature with a prideful carapace. The point is that each and every protagonist mattered and carried his, her/their weight beautifully and meaningfully. As a result, the characteristic multiple-perspectives-on-what-is-happening ensembles at the ends of Acts 2, 3 and 4, were immensely successful. Even the Chorus (Tanglewood Music Center Vocal Fellows) honed their youthful pastoral selves to perfection!
Cherubino (mezzo-soprano Emily d’Angelo) gave us a convincingly awkward teen-ager’s obsession with relentless libidinal urges, rendering “Non so più cosa son” with a marvelous sense of dismay. Nelsons’s orchestra deepened it psychologically to remind us that coming-of-age is no joke, hilarious as it seems to us. Cherubino absorbs the bad behaviors that surround him. Figaro delivered a powerful indictment of the propensity to send troublesome teenagers off to the army in a serio-ludere depiction of “la Gloria military” magnified by grimacing orchestral brass. And with the appearance of an exceptionally elegant but vulnerable and youthful Countess (Soprano Hanna-Elisabeth Müller), Act II subtly continued the thread of social criticism by cultivating a note of seriousness under the laughter, forcing the opera buffa to address inveterate cultural issues. As the lighting turned from red to yellow/gold, a superficially comical yet subtly dreadful Basilio (Rodell Rosel), brilliantly embodying the timeless busy body, reminded us that habits of mindless gossip have real consequences. The ensuing entangled action of multiple hidings pitted infidelity against jealousy in a stunningly self-absorbed Count Almaviva (Joshua Hopkins), signaling a privileged cad who is more blinded by vanity than evil and more enchained to social expectations than he realizes.At the end of Act II, when he kneels before Rosina and asks to be forgiven for accusing her of infidelity, he has a moment of actual insight: “From now on, we’ll try to know each other better.” Has he learned something? In Nelsons’ hands, Mozart’s score quickly added a note of pessimism. The concluding seven-voice ensemble, depicting seven different reactions to the same set of events, warned us that life is full of deceptive cadences and mock resolutions. Indeed, the lovely duet between Susanna and the Count that starts Act III, mingling scheming seduction on Susanna’s part with genuine weakness in Almaviva, quickly establishes that insights typically have only a short-term effect. And isn’t it amazing how unamplified voices can project in the shed, and how Nelsons allowed each of them full expression down to the loveliest pianissimos?
OK, I get it: the joy of reliving every moment of a brilliant, deep and impactful Nozze must be resisted. But surely I am allowed to evoke the memorable sextet “Riconosci in questo amplesso” as Marcellina recovers her lost child Figaro and welcomes her soon-to-be daughter-in-law? Even the very minor figure of Don Curzio (Tenor Joshua Sanders) mattered indispensably as the voice of the meddlesome cleric allied immorally with the ruling class! And thanks once again to Black’s shrewd stage-directing and to the subtle orchestral commentary, the far-fetched comic scene turned into a gentle teaching moment, as Marcellina accepts her age by finding a new dignity and status in generativity. (Who needs Erik Erikson when one has Nozze di Figaro done right?)

With dimmed lights and a nocturnal deep blue atmosphere, Act IV opened with a surprisingly affecting, even frankly arresting Barbarina (Eden Bartholomew). Often treated as a mere device through which to advance the plot, Barbarina’s “L’ho perduta” expanded into the darkness with the most haunting angst. Hearing it so shortly after the choir’s praise of Almaviva for abolishing his diritto feudale over young women, we could not help but hear in Barbarina’s anguish whole centuries of feudal abuse, hidden and white-washed. With Barberina’s lament in the background, the comic interplay of mistaken identities reveals covert insecurity and jealousy in the newlyweds Figaro and Susanna, but also forces Almaviva into self-examination. This brought the whole architecture of Mozart’s masterpiece to a simple but absolutely magnificent culmination: Almaviva repents. Kneeling down before Rosina, he asks for her forgiveness, undoing his own shabby disorder at least briefly, retracing his steps to their initial romance and retrieving something like an embryonic autonomous self of idealism and firm direction. Rosina forgives him. Why? Does she believe him? Does she remember him as he was? Or has she moved on from the sweet illusion of ideal love, displaying a capacity to believe in repentance in order to repair, reverse bad directions, give life a change and move on?
Anne Davenport is a scholar of early modern theology and philosophy. She has published books on medieval theories of infinity and Descartes. Her most recent book is “Suspicious Moderate” on the life and works of the 17th-century English Franciscan, Francis à Sancta Clara.

Donald, please forgive me for not stating my admiration of the chorus more clearly. I had such an overabundance of excellence to contend with! I loved the chorus. What I meant by “even” is similar to what I meant about Curzio: they mattered integrally to the magic of the performance. And each member of the chorus was marvelously individual, with recognizable individual personalities. As I emphasized, they embodied their characters convincingly and brought a real pastoral, youthful presence at a crucial moment. Indeed I don’t think that Barbarina’s aria would have been anywhere near as poignant if it hadn’t been for the chorus beforehand.
Comment by Anne Ashley Davenport — August 3, 2026 at 4:43 pm
Wonderful review, I just wonder at why the chorus is treated with such backhanded praise:
Even the Chorus (Tanglewood Music Center Vocal Fellows) honed their youthful pastoral selves to perfection!
Comment by Donald Irving — August 3, 2026 at 1:04 pm
@ Publius Again thanks for posting the link on the evening of the performance. Caught almost the entire opera and felt I was back in Vienna at the State Opera. Michael Sumuel (Figaro; MET) and Nikola Hillebrand (Susanna; Vienna State Opera) as well as the entire cast were excellent and the orchestra was mesmerizing. What a treat!
Comment by Kenny G — August 3, 2026 at 9:48 am
“Nelsons’s Nozze was nothing short of transformative.” — absolutely agree! The cast was really wonderful and I have become familiar with many of them from Symphony Hall concerts so I was always expecting an amazing perforamcne. I was absolutely transfixed in wonder while listening on the radio from the very start to end. I also love the commentary on WCRB and find that it always adds a lot to the broadcast. If anything, I am happy to spend intermissions in such a way.
Comment by Publius — August 3, 2026 at 8:41 am