IN: Reviews

Relentless Pursuit of the Edge

by

Composer Francisco Coll likes to push his artistic ideas to the very edge of expectation. In doing so, he immerses himself in various creative pursuits. He plays trombone, conducts, and even paints as he composes, often in tandem. On his sketches for new pieces, musical ideas mingle with blobs of paint as he works out issues of texture, line, and timbre. 

His full embrace of the arts runs so deep that he often paints depictions of his compositions. For his new Piano Concerto, which received its U.S. premiere Thursday night at Symphony Hall, he created a charcoal canvas bearing the same name. The picture riffs on the piano keyboard. The keys seem to burst out of the frame, an effect that feels both familiar and unsettling. But most of its energy emerges as the eyes track upward, revealing the keys vanishing into a field of white. 

The musical counterpart made for all-out fun. Kirill Gerstein’s performance of the concerto with Andris Nelsons and the Boston Symphony Orchestra conveyed every bit of raucous intensity while not taking itself too seriously. 

That effect alone makes the work a slight departure from one of its most obvious inspirations: Thomas Adès’s own Concerto for Piano and Orchestra, which Gerstein and the BSO premiered in 2019. Coll has long admired the British composer’s music. While living in Madrid, he sent Adès a few scores unsolicited. Adès responded by inviting Coll to study with him. (To date, Coll remains Adès’s only pupil.) The student adopted much of the master’s instinct for the daring and offbeat. Coll’s musical canvases are as vivid as his physical ones, bridging mid-20th-century collage and a firm sense of the past—a punkish with avantgarde as well as the tradition that bore it.

Yet Coll’s music frequently embraces humor as a compositional device. His Four Iberian Miniatures, which Adès led at the 2018 Festival of Contemporary Music, offers a whimsical look at Spanish dance rhythms. Its brash dissonances and glassy orchestral effects easily project the unease behind movements entitled “Schizophrenic.” Similarly, Coll’s Harpsichord Concerto places tongue firmly in cheek whenever it breaks into a kind of souped-up rag. The surrealist hilarity even manifests whenever Coll speaks about his music. In a video describing his compositional process for Mysteries of Humour, he explains his style while loudly grinding chopped vegetables. The noise drowns him out. But when he finishes, he quips that up to that point his approach had long been a secret.

Coll likens his style to the artwork of Salvador Dalí, who blended familiar elements in unexpected ways to create emotional tension. On the surface, Coll’s Piano Concerto follows the traditional three-movement format. But all comfort ends there. Across its 21-minute span, rhythms jolt in herky-jerky fashion, resembling ragtime just enough to keep the ear fixated. The orchestra unleashes all kinds of noises: woodwinds shriek, string dissonances stab at the air, and brasses shout out forcefully. Meanwhile, the pianist is tasked with throwing every kind of gesture at the keyboard. Scalar figures routinely crash into powerful chords. And the soloist even smacks the keys—childlike— with an open palm. 

The second movement contains the most arresting moments. Wind and string phrases form thick clouds of dissonance that hang in the air. Under that, the pianist unfolds phrases that could be at home in a Rachmaninoff concerto. But Coll again distorts the texture to avoid any lingering homage. That never lets the music settle into an equilibrium. Everything feels nervous and on edge.

But rather than offering resolution, the finale drives the tension to near breaking point. This music here channels all bluster and fire, more of a slam dance than a feel-good fling. Gerstein and Nelsons worked in ideal tandem to render the concerto with abandon. Gerstein rewarded the applause with the delightfully off-kilter “Little Viennese Waltz” from Coll’s Two Waltzes Toward Civilization. 

Andris Nelsons  two concerts back (Audience member photo)

The rest of the program focused on Beethoven, with the composer’s Symphony No. 7 amplifying the intensity.

Beethoven struck a new direction with this score from 1812 that reflected neither the heroism of his earlier symphonies nor the deep introspection of his later string quartets. Every movement drives forward with rhythmic zest, which Nelsons made infectious.

After lingering in the opening sections, the Latvian conductor kept the tempos propelling forward. The first movement’s jig-like theme bounded playfully, though Nelsons avoided the exposition repeat. 

The Allegretto unfolded like a study in gradual processes. Even as the rhythm churned, Nelsons worked his usual magic by drawing a funereal grandeur from the cellos and basses. Layer by layer, he built the music to satisfying heights that never tipped the balance into excess. 

The fugue moved with purpose. So did the giddy Scherzo and bucolic Trio, offset only by some flubbed wind entrances. Beethoven intended the finale to convey a state of near delirium. Nelsons pushed the tempo so hard that the orchestra could barely contain the energy. The result brought the audience to its feet.

Even Beethoven’s Coriolan Overture, which opened the concert, coursed urgently. The strings may have taken time to get their running figures in sync. But this remained a dramatic reading: tense, foreboding, and biting in all the right places. It was a fresh reminder that Beethoven, too, pushed at the boundaries of possibility. 

Aaron Keebaugh’s work has been featured in The Musical Times, Corymbus, The Classical Review, Early Music America, BBC Radio 3, and the Arts Fuse, for which he writes regularly about classical music. A musicologist, Aaron teaches at North Shore Community College in Danvers and Lynn.

12 Comments »

12 Comments [leave a civil comment (others will be removed) and please disclose relevant affiliations]

  1. Beethoven 7th Was Outstanding

    Comment by Marcia L Jackson — October 12, 2026 at 3:17 pm

  2. PS: I’m thinking of Astor Piazzolla who understood that the tango was not just only a rhythmic dance form but also a dance with death and tragedy.

    Comment by Sam Sollitt — October 11, 2026 at 1:22 pm

  3. @ Sam W Thanks for the brief excerpt. It reminds me of Jonny Greenwood’s soundtrack for the P.T. Anderson film One Battle After Another. His soundtrack brilliantly accompanied the film’s many chase scenes. To clarify my earlier remarks, I’m perfectly fine with rhythmically driven pieces as long as the composer can also create moods and atmosphere (tonally or atonally) in other segments of the composition. Slow speeds show a composer’s skill in contemplation and immersion. These moments of contemplation often require empathy and compassion and not just mere exhilaration or sensations of excitement. A mood is a thinking disposition towards the world and reflects a type of emotional intelligence and not just a response via the sensorium of sound.

    Comment by Sam Sollitt — October 11, 2026 at 12:57 pm

  4. I should rely less on sarcasm and put up more of a defense of Coll’s piano concerto. I found it fascinating and exhilarating. If you immerse yourself in it and pay attention, it is not at all scattershot or directionless, though it is constantly changing direction, dissecting its rhythms to create new ones, giving us wisps of familiar sounds only to snatch them away. I particularly liked the way the piano kept on joining up with other instruments, such as the harp and various bells, to make quite original, and very musical sounds. It was not particularly dissonant, either. There were many old-fashioned harmonic effects, though used in unfamiliar wayd. The very beautiful end of second movement leaves us hanging one note short of the resolution of the final chord, an effect only possible if the laws of chordal harmony are guiding our hearing.

    It is a bit much to take in unless you are committed. I suggest watching/listening to this 2-minute excerpt from the premiere performance, with a conductor, and perhaps an ensemble, somewhat more sympathetic to, and committed to, the work.

    https://www.facebook.com/BRSO/videos/-world-premiere-francisco-coll-piano-concertocommissioned-by-the-brso-the-boston/874873845605274/

    Comment by SamW — October 11, 2026 at 10:32 am

  5. The other composer on the program, Ludwig van Beethoven, was regarded by many in his time as a near-savage for his indulgence in strident rhythms and extreme climaxes, pushing for dramatic effects without consideration to euphony or good taste. The violence and cacophony of his Grosse Fugue were considered near-insane. Well, it was a time of great upheaval in the world. Perhaps his popularity among the younger folk was a sign of the decline of good taste in an age of anxiety.

    Comment by SamW — October 11, 2026 at 10:03 am

  6. @ Seth I did not attend the concert but get your reservations about percussive dominance in modern classical pieces. Wilhelm Worringer’s art theory argues that abstraction (rhythm, percussion) are an expression of the anxiety or dread of space. We see the onset of increased abstraction in post-Romantics like Mahler or Shostakovich who frequently resort to militaristic rhythms. However, their amazing adagios still show the capacity to express empathy and embrace the world. Similar shifts can be noted in pop music where R&B with its warm expressive melodic lines has given way to a harsher cynical hip hop recitative and percussive style. It could be an expression of our anxious times or it could reflect our growing incapacity to show genuine empathy and care. Take your pick.

    Comment by Sam Sollitt — October 11, 2026 at 8:49 am

  7. Seth, I was at the Saturday performance and find myself in agreement with you. The concerto seemed to be just scattered, mostly dissonant bits that never cohered into something that I enjoyed.

    The audience response was wildly in favor of the Beethoven symphony, giving it one of the most enthusiastic standing ovations I’ve seen at an orchestral concert. Multiple people were literally humming or singing some of their favorite bits on their way from the seats to the street. I was very impressed by the clarity, dynamics, and power that the musicians brought to the piece.

    Comment by Brandon — October 11, 2026 at 8:25 am

  8. Thank you, Dennis. That’s consistent with what the seating charts showed.

    I spoke with someone who attended Friday’s concert. She said, “large portions of the orchestra after the break were completely empty, the floor sides had many empty seats as well, and the second balcony was perhaps 1/3 full.”

    Comment by Mogulmeister — October 10, 2026 at 12:13 pm

  9. according to an usher Thursday night, the attendance was around 1500. 60%

    Comment by Dennis Lee Milford — October 10, 2026 at 11:22 am

  10. The Boston Classical Review favorably observes: “One of the best aspects of Andris Nelsons’ tenure as music director of the Boston Symphony Orchestra has been the conductor’s advocacy for a wide swath of contemporary composers.” Yet management complains that Nelsons’s repertoire is too traditional, i.e. no pop-music component, because he certainly covers contemporary music. Let’s drop the charade and appoint Keith Lockhart as the new MD and cover the classical program with guest conductors. Why all the NDAs and secrecy? Simply announce your plans openly and see what the audience thinks. For me, this not so hidden shift in emphasis spells the end of the BSO and I have stopped attending concerts.

    Comment by erich kessler — October 10, 2026 at 9:15 am

  11. Hello Mogulmeister,

    Thursday night’s concert was pretty full. A few scattered empty seats. But a great turnout—-much better than the Mahler 7 performance.

    Hope that helps. I can check with the press office for more accurate numbers.

    Comment by Aaron Keebaugh — October 10, 2026 at 8:48 am

  12. Aaron, a fine review – as usual. Can you tell us how full Symphony Hall was Thursday night? The seating chart prior to the concert suggested the hall was 50% full. Is that what you saw?

    Comment by Mogulmeister — October 10, 2026 at 8:26 am

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Leave a comment