IN: Reviews

Edward Cohen Memorial Concert at MIT   

by

The Thomas Tull Concert Hall at MIT, in the year-old music building [see BMInt feature HERE], is a theater-in-the-round with a resonant wooden floor, not quite 400 seats across the flat floor and raked tiers, excellent lighting, and live, close sound, makes a good location for small orchestras such as the one that honored the memory of MIT composer Edward Cohen (1940-2002) last night. A major work of his, Stone and Earth (1978), took pride of place in a fine varied program of works by MIT composers, along with the premiere of a Divertimento by the Manhattan School of Music’s Marjorie Merryman, who was married to Eddie for many years. She was present, and in her pre-concert remarks, as she talked about him and his eclectic style and manner, there were a lot of nods of recognition in the audience of about 110, many of whom, including me, had known him.

MIT Collage

I had not previously heard any music by Charles Shadle, who teaches music history and theory, but was not surprised to find that he was a brother of Douglas Shadle, an Americanist whom I knew from meetings of the American Musicological Society. Charles Shadle’s Song of Removal (2024), received a warmly executed premiere performance. It is a lovely midrange piece with an elegant tonal ambience, moving smoothly in long melodic lines between a triadic harmony and carefully clustered tones; the thematic basis is “a uniquely Choctaw variant of William Walker’s shape-note hymn, “Star in the East,” according to notes by the composer, himself a member of the Choctaw nation in Oklahoma. The G minor harmony evoked the natural minor of the New England colonial hymnodists, subtly twinged here and there with chromatic dodges to B minor and elsewhere.

Marjorie Merryman’s Divertimento, described by the composer as “not entirely a light-hearted diversion,” was bouncy and often chromatic in long lines with varied textures, and with an agreeable distribution of registers in thirds and sixths from top to bottom. A few faint echoes of familiar string-orchestra harmony, from Honegger’s Symphony No. 2 and Stravinsky’s Symphony in Three Movements, provided a nice overall environment, but this happy diversion, could have gone on for at least one more minute.

Cohen composed Stone and Earth for mezzo-soprano and string orchestra 1978, during his first year of teaching at MIT, and debued there that year. The text, by the 17th-century poet Henry Vaughan, is post-Miltonian and not entirely sane, but full of images resonating in song. Cohen’s accompaniment is dominated by a nocturnal, even stony chromatic harmony, faintly tonal with cautious surges of repeated figures, rather as though Copland had met Max Reger in a deep forest, and with notable dramatic pauses. Krista River, mezzo-soprano, gave expressive punctuation to the very concentrated string sound. Marjorie Merryman’s notes aptly stated: “…he created a delicate continuity of harmonic, rhythmic, and melodic connections.” This was rightly the centerpiece of the concert, and one wanted to hear it again, not waiting 48 years.

John Harbison was present to hear the premiere of the string-orchestra version (originally for string quartet, but adding a contrabass part) of his Four Encores for Stan (2013), a commission from the Minnesota Chamber Music Society as a birthday piece for Stanisław Skrowaczewski, longtime director of the Minneapolis Orchestra. The four, minute-long movements explored dialogues between the string sections, call-and-response, and bitonal chordal textures. Krista River provided a narration between the pieces, with brief texts drawn from Skrowaczewski’s writings for bemused audiences.

Peter Child’s Sinfonietta of 1998 wrapped up the evening. Four movements put forward a considerable D minor, with well-planned rhythmic measures, dotted patterns, and refreshing tonal departures (even a B-flat-F boom-chick plucked bass) in lively succession. The second movement had mordent-like twitches, the fourth movement a busy fughetta, and an eloquent slow third movement in long, ornamented songlike lines with many parallel thirds, which sound so well in divided upper-register strings. There could have been, at a stretch, a faint comparison with Britten’s Simple Symphony, but this not-at-all simplistic Sinfonietta is more like Bloch’s Concerto Grosso, and more up-to-date in harmony.

David Hoose, conducting, elegantly and unobtrusively, brought all this cozy gathering together. After the concert I overheard someone say that Peter Child is an “American Poulenc,” which might be an acceptable epithet, but one tempered by the fact that three of the five composers represented on the concert were educated at Brandeis University, and that none of them exhibited serialist rigor or the style sévère that Princeton and Brandeis emblazoned for so many years. As David Hoose stressed in his opening remarks, how all of the works on the program were vastly different from each other, and how Eddie Cohen would have liked that.

Mark DeVoto, musicologist and composer, is an expert on the music of Alban Berg, Debussy, and other early 20th-century composers. A graduate of Harvard College (1961) and Princeton (Ph.D., 1967), he has published on many music subjects, and edited the revised fourth (1978) and fifth (1987) editions of Harmony by his teacher Walter Piston.

5 Comments »

5 Comments [leave a civil comment (others will be removed) and please disclose relevant affiliations]

  1. Thank you for a thorough review of a very special evening.

    “Elegant and unobtrusive” might accurately describe David Hoose’s conducting on a purely visual level, but the very high level of playing and uncanny sense of musical unanimity suggest a brilliant and forceful musical mind behind the musical preparation. It’s a pleasure to have him on the podium again.

    Comment by Michael Beattie — October 11, 2026 at 10:45 pm

  2. This thoughtful and lovely review is much appreciated….however, although I know and admire his work, Douglas Shadle is NOT my brother. To the best of my knowledge we are not related.

    Comment by Charles Shadle — October 11, 2026 at 10:31 pm

  3. Sorry for the confusion. I switched out the incorrect photo a couple of hours ago

    Comment by Lee Eiseman — October 11, 2026 at 4:58 pm

  4. The photos are definitely of Edward Cohen. The one with Eddie in his bow tie was taken on his wedding day to Marjorie Merryman, and the one on the bottom right of him running a marathon, etc. Whether the one in front of the staff-lined blackboard was at Brandeis, Harvard, or MIT, I can’t say. But all are of him, a wonderful person and musician.

    Comment by David — October 11, 2026 at 4:56 pm

  5. Was the picture intended to be one of Eddie Cohen? I’m pretty sure that’s Morton Feldman. I can see how someone might make that mistake, though. I didn’t even notice until I had read the whole article.

    Comment by Alan — October 11, 2026 at 2:53 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Leave a comment