
Guest conductor Kent Nagano bound together this weekend’s Boston Symphony Orchestra program. The bill closes with Mendelssohn’s Symphony No. 5, the “Reformation.” That’s preceded by the US premiere of Argentine composer Alex Nante’s Ein’ feste Burg, which is thematically linked to the symphony and which Nante composed on a commission from the Dresden Philharmonic at Nagano’s request. Opening the program is another Mendelssohn work, his concert overture The Hebrides. And Nagano is a longtime champion of Tod Machover, whose BSO-commissioned already and not yet was to have its world premiere. Symphony Hall was reasonably well filled Thursday; the tumultuous applause that greeted Machover when he appeared suggested that a sizeable MIT contingent was in place. I had reservations about already and not yet, but Ein’ feste Burg and the Mendelssohn pieces were a joy.
The Hebrides was inspired by a boat trip the composer made to the Inner Hebrides isle of Staffa in 1829. Mendelssohn sent his sister Fanny a postcard with the opening subject, but he didn’t actually finish this 10-minute work till 1832, after writing to Fanny, “The middle part, forte in D major, is very stupid, and savors more of counterpoint than of oil or dead fish.” With that “very stupid” section rewritten, The Hebrides debuted at the Philharmonic Society in London in 1832.
The name has been an issue. Mendelssohn’s original title was Die einsame Insel (“The Lonely Isle”). Eventually he settled on Die Hebriden (“The Hebrides”). When Breitkopf & Härtel published the piece in 1834, the orchestral parts bore that title, but the score itself appeared as Fingals Höhle (“Fingal’s Cave”), as Staffa’s famous basalt cave is popularly known. By any name, the piece has been popular in Boston; George Henschel led the BSO premiere in 1883, and the orchestra had performed it nearly 200 times prior to Thursday.
When Riccardo Chailly and the Gewandhausorchester Leipzig brought The Hebrides to Symphony Hall in 2014, the first and second violins were antiphonally seated. Nagano had the regular current BSO set-up, with the violins all grouped on his left, but the power and mystery of his reading equaled Chailly’s, or the one we got from Benjamin Zander and the Boston Philharmonic in 2021. At no point did the middle section savor of oil or dead fish; why Mendelssohn thought that would be a desirable effect is a puzzle.
This Hebrides began in bright sunshine and dead calm, and the second subject, starting in the cellos and bassoons, was soothing, but the sea soon became choppy and a brief fanfare from the trumpets suggested a gathering of gulls. An ominous return to the first subject from the flutes (Elizabeth Klein and Clint Foreman) and then solo flute and clarinet (Klein and William R. Hudgins) ushered in the first storm, whose violence seemed to confirm the report from Mendelssohn’s traveling companion that he got seasick on the ride out to Staffa. There was certainly a sense of sea swell when the second subject returned in the development. The recapitulation brought a seductive siren duet from the clarinets (Hudgins and Christopher Elchico), but then the third storm hit, Nagano taking the coda Animato as marked and observing the lower strings’ non legato. The tempest seemed to blow itself out, leaving Hudgins’s clarinet and Klein’s flute to meditate on the mystery that remained. Or perhaps they were simply marking the lull before the next storm.
already and not yet is the musical component of the BSO’s “Technology and Our Humanity” initiative, which asks, “How is technology reshaping not only music, but also our understanding of ourselves and one another?” Machover, who is the faculty director of the MIT Media Lab, takes what he calls a “provocative first step” with this 32-minute piece. In his program note, he describes the first of the three movements, “SMASH UP,” as “a musical depiction of clash and crisis.” In “WAKE UP,” a live AI system “creates variations and enhancements on individual solo lines across the orchestra.” Finally, he imagines “STAND UP” as “a growing, multi-layered vision of a future democracy, where the AI helps balance detail, texture, and polyphony while extending sound off the stage into the hall.” The piece’s title, he says, “refers to the state of the world and of our country, prepared to be shaped and with much to appreciate, but unfinished, imperfect and urgently in need of pushing forward.”
Machover came on stage Thursday to give a brief and helpful introduction for anyone who hadn’t perused the program book. He explained that AI would not be creating sounds, only reacting sensitively to what the orchestra did. He directed our attention to MIT Media Lab sound artist Manaswi Mishra, who had taken up a spot among the violas; Mishra designed the AI system for already and not yet and would be controlling it live.

“SMASH UP” did bring a sense of “clash and crisis,” mostly from screeching brass shouting down mournful strings. The attempt at conversation came to a standstill and the music seemed to move like an automaton, unsure of its direction, finally dying out after about seven minutes. Solo winds came to the fore at the outset of “WAKE UP,” alto flute (Clint Foreman) leading the way, then, it seemed, clarinet (Hudgins), horn (Richard Sebring), and bassoon (Josh Baker). The brass stood down and a more productive conversation ensued; I heard echoes of Charles Ives and began to sense some of what Mishra was doing.
“STAND UP” looked to build on all that with a more sophisticated notion of communication, but I found this third movement difficult to follow. The program book advises us that “some of the vocal sounds heard in several sections of already and not yet were recorded for this piece by the Carduus Ensemble, conducted by Holly Druckman.” I detected just one brief vocal midway through “STAND UP” and couldn’t make out the words, if there were any. The trombones and tuba had their moment. A kind of harmony of the spheres might have marked the finish but didn’t. A big climax with jazzy syncopation looked to be the end but wasn’t. Sitting at the back of the second balcony, I didn’t detect sound extending “off the stage into the hall.” I didn’t detect AI doing much of anything.
already and not yet finished quietly. The applause for Nagano, the orchestra, and Machover, when he returned, was, I thought, appreciably more fervent than the reception for the piece itself. Nagano had appeared composed and confident on the podium; he seemed to know exactly where already and not yet was going and what it was about. I envied him.
Ein’ feste Burg takes its name from the 16th-century Lutheran hymn “Ein’ feste Burg ist unser Gott” (“A Mighty Fortress Is Our God”), which Bach used in his Cantata BWV 80 and turned into a chorale for BWV 302. In his program note, Nante explains that Nagano asked him “to preserve the original chorale of BWV 302 throughout, in the manner of Leopold Stokowski’s arrangement of the same work.” He continues, “At the same time, the idea was not simply to write an orchestration of the chorale.”
Ein’ feste Burg is anything but a mere orchestration. It begins pianissimo, in the stratosphere. On Thursday, it followed the intermission. The audience had applauded Nagano’s return to the stage and was surely aware that Nante’s piece had started, but the music was barely audible, and a fair degree of coughing and snack-bag crinkling and the seating of latecomers marred the opening minute. Nothing could have marred the seven or so minutes that followed, as the violins conversed with the clarinets, that spread to the winds and strings in general, the brass entered, Lorna McGhee contributed a gleaming flute solo, and Nante introduced all manner of revelatory counterpoint. His conclusion was inspired as well: a massive tutti gives way to a coda based on another Bach chorale, the sorrowful BWV 500a, whose text begins “So gehst du nun, mein Jesu, hin, den Tod für mich zu leiden” (“So now you go there, Jesus, to suffer death in my stead”).
I was confused when this somber finish changed course, and it took me a moment to realize that Nagano had continued straight into the Mendelssohn symphony, without pausing to signal that Nante’s piece had ended or giving the audience a chance to applaud. When the audience did applaud after the symphony’s first movement, I wondered whether some people didn’t think Ein’ feste Burg had just finished. On the other hand, the Scherzo also drew applause, and the Andante third movement might have if Nagano hadn’t moved directly into the finale.
Mendelssohn’s Symphony No. 5 was actually his second in order of composition. He began work in 1829, with the idea of having it performed the following year in Berlin as part of the 300th anniversary of the Augsburg Confession, the Lutheran Church’s primary confession of faith. He didn’t complete the symphony in time, however, and he made revisions before the eventual Berlin premiere in 1832. By 1838, he was dismissing it as “a piece of juvenilia”; it wouldn’t be performed again for another 30 years.
Its nickname, “Reformation,” was suggested by Fanny Mendelssohn and derives from Felix’s use of “Ein’ feste Burg ist unser Gott” in the last movement. In the first movement, Mendelssohn introduced the “Dresden Amen,” a seven-note cadential phrase composed in the late 18th century that was popular in both Lutheran and Catholic churches. (Wagner adopted it as Parsifal’s “Grail” motif.) The Andante opens with a version of the traditional Hebrew folk song “Hevenu Shalom Aleichem” (“We greet you with peace”). So though the symphony closes with “Ein’ feste Burg,” one can imagine Mendelssohn might have been looking to transcend denominationalism.
Like The Hebrides, the “Reformation” enjoyed an early BSO debut, Henschel leading it in 1882. In 1957, Charles Munch and the BSO made a recording that was well received then and still is today. Andris Nelsons did it here just two years ago and has recorded it with the Gewandhausorchester. Boston has also gotten to hear—from Chailly and the Gewandhaus, on the same 2014 program with The Hebrides—the symphony’s original version. The finale is what’s most different. Mendelssohn’s first thought was to start with a kind of flute recitative that goes on for two minutes before the flute leads the rest of the winds into “Ein’ feste Burg.” This magical moment makes the preceding two minutes redundant, and Mendelssohn was right to excise them. And the original conclusion, a big restatement of the finale’s first subject, gave way to “Ein’ feste Burg” as a closing chorale. That too was a major improvement.

Nagano’s “Reformation” was of a piece with his Hebrides. The Palestrinian polyphony of the D-major introduction went at a proper Andante, the hush of the “Dresden Amen” transported us into a sacred space for a few seconds, and then the D-minor Allegro con fuoco exposition burst forth with the necessary fire. Nagano didn’t slow for the second subject, but the return of the “Dresden Amen,” just before the recapitulation, caused the first subject to become quiet, almost abashed, and to effect a détente with the second theme. That didn’t last into the coda, which recaptured the movement’s initial unrepentant defiance.
Nagano took the B-flat-major Scherzo at a more relaxed clip than the Allegro vivace tempo marking might suggest, but it did provide a breather after the opening fireworks; the lilting Trio, with its playful winds and serene strings, was genial and gracious. I thought he found the right stiff-upper-lip tempo for the G-minor Andante, which often comes off as an Adagio, and the movement benefitted no end from McGhee’s solo flute and Richard Svoboda’s solo bassoon. It slides into G major in the last bars, and that’s the key when the flute takes up “Ein’ feste Burg” to begin the finale.
McGhee and the rest of the wind section were spellbinding here; Nagano made the beginning of the Allegro maestoso exposition militant as well as majestic and achieved great clarity in the fugal sections; Thomas Martin’s solo clarinet highlighted the serene development. The brass led the return of the reconciliatory second subject, which seems to anticipate the good-feeling finale of Robert Schumann’s Second Symphony. Nagano followed Mendelssohn’s direction to speed up gradually at the beginning of the coda, and unlike many conductors, he resisted the temptation to slow dramatically for the final “Ein’ feste Burg” chorale. I was left wondering what a “future democracy” could offer that would be better than this.
Jeffrey Gantz has been writing about music, dance, theater, art, film, and books for the past 45 years, first for the Boston Phoenix and currently for the Boston Globe.

Durable link to the recording: https://cpa.ds.npr.org/s1142/audio/2026/10/bso-261024-online-1.mp3
Listening to the Nagano again.
Comment by John Shriver — November 5, 2026 at 6:18 pm
Gentlemen, please read my comment carefully
Specifically, please read the first word…..often.
M-W does not define the word “often’ as always, it doesn’t even define it as most of the time.
So I stand by my claim – often when I hear new music I feel someone is shouting at me for 30 minutes.
And, rest assured I listen to, and like, much of the new music available in the world today.
Comment by Cecilia — November 2, 2026 at 1:11 pm
@Publius – Yes, it does. In that sense, Cecilia is correct here. Just making the broad, general assumption that all new music is like that is something I take umbrage with. That would be like saying all non-Mozart Classical period music sounds like Haydn. It’s simply not true.
Comment by Ian Wiese — November 2, 2026 at 8:00 am
@ Ian — Funnily enough, the review of this concert makes mention of “…screeching brass shouting down mournful strings.” I do not necessarily think Cecilia is wrong here.
Comment by Publius — November 1, 2026 at 7:59 pm
Cecilia, I feel that the attitude you bring to new music isn’t completely fair to new music. Composers aren’t doing something for the sake of being different; we write what we feel is appropriate for the moment, like everyone else who came before us. I’d encourage you to listen to more new music pieces and see if we still are “shouting at [you] for 30 minutes” in them, because there’s a wide variety of styles and practices and approaches abound.
Comment by Ian Wiese — November 1, 2026 at 5:01 pm
Author
Catherine Hudgins
From The Berkshire Eagle Tuesday October 27,, 2026
BSO patron files complaint with Massachusetts attorney general over Nelsons decision
The filing seeks a review by the state attorney general on how BSO leaders decided not to extend Andris Nelsons’ contract beyond next summer.
Clarence Fanto
THE BERKSHIRE EAGLE
PUBLISHED Tuesday, October 27, 2026 – 1:45 p.m.
BOSTON — The fallout over the Boston Symphony board of trustees’ decision not to extend Music Director Andris Nelsons’ contract following next summer’s Tanglewood season entered the legal arena Tuesday.
Long-time BSO patron and journalist Stephen Landrigan, a Boston native, submitted a complaint to Massachusetts Attorney General Andrea Joy Campbell seeking “a review of how the BSO’s management and board made, and oversaw, the decision not to renew Nelsons’ contract.”
The complaint “does not challenge any artistic judgment or ask that Nelsons be reinstated,” Landrigan wrote. “Rather, I am alleging breaches of fiduciary duty and mismanagement of charitable assets.”
Specifically, he challenged the “consistent deficits and a drained endowment” described by President and CEO Chad Smith after the decision was announced March 6.
The attorney general’s Nonprofits and Charities Division is reviewing the complaint, according to Molly McGlynn, communications director for Attorney General Campbell.
The BSO had no immediate comment on the complaint.
Asked by The Eagle to explain why he filed the complaint, Landrigan responded: “I want to see the trustees wake up to the fact that in their name, a terrible thing has been done, and they can undo it.”
Smith has declared consistently during media interviews that reinstatement of Nelsons is off the table.
Landrigan, in his filing with the state attorney general, took issue with Smith’s description of the BSO’s finances.
“The BSO’s own Form 990 filings, as analyzed by independent analyst Thomas Dinsmore, show 13 surpluses and 7 deficits since fiscal 2006 and an endowment of about $603 million, its highest ever,” Landrigan pointed out. “On information and belief, the notice for the Feb. 2 vote did not name non-renewal as a purpose, and the board then felt compelled to reaffirm its decision twice.”
The complaint does not allege that Smith knew his financial statements were inaccurate, Landrigan said.
BSO chief denies agreement to extend Andris Nelsons’ contract past 2027
“It asks the attorney general to determine what [Smith] told the board, what he knew, and why the descriptions differ from the IRS filings,” Landrigan said.
Landrigan told The Eagle that he is asking Campbell to determine the facts, including a review of “consulting and vendor spending, possible conflicts of interest and what donors were told about Mr. Nelsons’ tenure.”
The complaint seeks a review of the accuracy of the financial information given to trustees, donors and the public, and the oversight of that information.
The legal document also asks whether donors were told about the board’s decision on Nelsons as the BSO raised funds, given the BSO’s January 2024 announcement of an “evergreen” contract for the music director.
It also asks whether any gift, pledge or condition tied to the decision was disclosed to the board and reviewed under the BSO’s conflict-of-interest policy. Landrigan stated that he does not allege that any such offer was made.
The announcement of Nelsons’ abbreviated tenure came five weeks after the trustees’ Feb. 2 vote. The decision startled and angered many of the orchestra’s musicians, who had not been consulted or informed before the news was revealed to the public, the staff and the media late on Friday afternoon, March 6.
Smith described a “lack of alignment” between the leadership and Nelsons on the future vision for the BSO.
Protests followed, with many BSO musicians and audience members wearing red flowers in Boston and then at Tanglewood last summer in support of Nelsons. The musicians voiced near-unanimous backing, urging his reinstatement, to no avail.
A grassroots effort led by the BSO Patrons Action Network included the distribution of the red flowers to members of the public and the placement of signs supporting Nelsons on roadsides in Lenox and surrounding communities, some of which are still visible.
The Players Committee, backed by the Boston Musicians Association union, reached a contract agreement with the BSO several days after the previous contract expired on Aug. 23.
The three-year agreement gives the musicians pay increases and a greater voice in artistic decisions, including the eventual selection of a new music director. Management hailed the agreement as reflecting an enhanced “spirit of collaboration.”
Nelsons has declined formal comment beyond a prepared statement on March 6, emphasizing that the management’s decision was not what he anticipated or wanted. That statement also said that his removal “was not related to artistic standards, performances, or achievements during my tenure.” He has told supporters that he wanted to stay.
Nelsons’ managers and BSO executives differed on whether Nelsons had been offered an emeritus role with the orchestra, and on whether he had been informed that negotiations to extend his contract were in jeopardy.
Landrigan’s complaint filed Tuesday morning asks Attorney General Campbell to consider “corrective measures such as an independent governance and financial review, corrective public disclosure, stronger conflict-of-interest procedures and board education on oversight duties.”
“Because the BSO receives federal and state public funds,” the complaint states, “the public interest in the accuracy of its financial representations is heightened.”
Landrigan, 78, is now a freelance book editor and writer. Formerly, he worked for The Washington Post in London and for BBC Radio in Washington, D.C., after starting as a journalist on newspapers in western Pennsylvania and upstate New York.
“I have been attending Boston Symphony concerts since 1959, and have seen how the orchestra has flourished under Andris Nelsons,” Landrigan said. “I am asking that a decision as important as dismissing him rest on accurate information and a process that the public can trust.”
Comment by erich kessler — October 28, 2026 at 4:54 pm
Nagano as conductor was efficient and acceptable in my estimation as a guest conductor. But the palette of the orchestra as a whole was limited when compared with Nelsons on the podium. Yes it was correct – mostly, although there was a place in the Symphony where it did not jell for a few moments – but the music did not come alive as it does with our Latvian superstar.
And… Pops conductor Keith Lockhart was on one of the GBH afternoon radio shows a few weeks ago and was asked about the Nelsons controversy. He answered with something pc written by his agent, or maybe the PR firm the BSO has hired to deal with it. The gist of what he said was that the Board and musicians had signed a contract and everyone was working together in collaborative harmony (pun intended) to continue and build on the wonderful orchestra the BSO has been.
So, have you heard anything from the Board or Chad that sounds collaborative? Have you even seen or heard anything from them as active participants? I haven’t, and for me their silence speaks loads.
Comment by Cecilia — October 26, 2026 at 6:14 pm
Often when I hear ‘new’ music I comment that it feels like someone is shouting at me for 30 minutes. That was close to what I felt Saturday night listening to the Machover. Being different for the sake of being different is how I view the work. Not my cup of tea.
Comment by Cecilia — October 26, 2026 at 4:37 pm
Listened last night to WCRB as well and asked AI to turn off the program during the Machover piece. Listened instead to the gorgeous Nelsons Mahler cycle that has just been released. Also, the Berlin Digital Concert Hall offered a free concert earlier in the day of the orchestra on tour in Buenos Aires, playing Brahms Piano Concerto 1 and Straussʻs Zarathustra.
Comment by Sam Sollitt — October 25, 2026 at 3:29 pm
@ John Shriver — I did my best to listen to the concert last night on WCRB/99.5 FM, but I had to turn it off midway through the Machover/AI piece.
Comment by Publius — October 25, 2026 at 9:45 am
I was there Friday afternoon, in orchestra row Y. The sound from the speakers did move into the hall, at times it sounded to be overhead. But it was never behind me, so it wasn’t going to get close to the rear of the second balcony. The young woman controlling the mixer was at row W, so it was mixed for that listening position. The singers were heard more than you probably heard.
The audience was similarly confused by the “curve ball” of no pause between Nante’s work and the Symphony. But they did get quiet before the start. I plan to listen again on the radio today and record it.
Comment by John Shriver — October 24, 2026 at 12:48 pm